研读新知 · 每日简报研读新知DAILY BRIEFING

加载中
Daily Academic Briefing

研读新知 · 每日简报

NERV TOKYO-3 HQ
OPERATIONAL STATUS: FLUO. GREEN: ONLINE
MAGI SYSTEM DASHBOARD
CENTRAL COMMAND
MELCHIOR GREEN
BALTHASAR GREEN
CASPAR GREEN
Public Administration Review 期刊封面

Public Administration Review

深入基层:公共服务生态系统微观层面下的人类服务供给思考与理论化

Kate Broadhurst, Steven Parker

英文原题

Digging Into the Subsoil: Considering and Theorizing Human Services Delivery at the Sub‐Micro‐Level of the Public Service Ecosystem

公共服务常常与家庭和社区合作提供,然而这些关系在公共服务生态系统(PSE)理论中受到的关注有限。为响应发展 PSE 亚微观层面的呼吁,我们引入“底层敏感性”这一概念,以凸显支撑公共服务价值创造的家庭和社区生态系统。这些非正式系统是价值创造与破坏的活跃场所,其敏感性源于它们与公共服务的契合或错位。我们提出立法和政策节点作为连接器,将宏观政策转化为微观实践。借助…

阅读完整摘要 ↗
公共服务常常与家庭和社区合作提供,然而这些关系在公共服务生态系统(PSE)理论中受到的关注有限。为响应发展 PSE 亚微观层面的呼吁,我们引入“底层敏感性”这一概念,以凸显支撑公共服务价值创造的家庭和社区生态系统。这些非正式系统是价值创造与破坏的活跃场所,其敏感性源于它们与公共服务的契合或错位。我们提出立法和政策节点作为连接器,将宏观政策转化为微观实践。借助儿童保护案例,我们展示了节点如何创造互动条件,而底层动态则在权力不对称和不同信仰体系背景下影响价值是共同创造还是共同破坏。本文扩展了 PSE 的亚微观层面,并为审视公共服务提供中的家庭和社区生态系统提供了一个框架。
查看原文摘要
Public services are often delivered in partnership with families and communities, yet these relationships receive limited attention within public service ecosystem (PSE) theory. Responding to call to develop the sub‐micro‐level of the PSE, we introduce the concept of subsoil sensitivity to foreground the family and community ecosystems that underpin public service value creation. These informal systems are active sites of value creation and destruction with sensitivities arising from their alignment or misalignment with public services. We propose legislative and policy nodes as connectors that translate macrolevel policy into microlevel practice. Drawing on child protection vignettes, we show how nodes create the conditions for interaction, while subsoil dynamics influence whether value is cocreated or codestroyed amid power asymmetries and differing belief systems. The paper extends the sub‐micro‐level of the PSE and offers a framework for examining family and community ecosystems in public service delivery.

对抗性政治虚构、公共行政与民粹主义及威权冲动时代的民主

Michael W. Spicer

英文原题

Dueling Political Fictions and Public Administration and Democracy in an Era of Populism and Authoritarian Impulses

英国内战时期政治话语中所运用的政治虚构,对于当代公共政策与行政管理仍具有现实意义。主流公共行政话语往往采用了这一时期出现的单一且无界的民众主权虚构,致使公共行政在面对当代民粹主义政府的威权冲动时显得力不从心。在应对这些威权冲动时,公共行政话语所需的并非传统上主导我们领域的行政中立伦理,而是一种宪政伦理,这种伦理借鉴了英国内战时期英国平等派以及随后美国宪法奠基…

阅读完整摘要 ↗
英国内战时期政治话语中所运用的政治虚构,对于当代公共政策与行政管理仍具有现实意义。主流公共行政话语往往采用了这一时期出现的单一且无界的民众主权虚构,致使公共行政在面对当代民粹主义政府的威权冲动时显得力不从心。在应对这些威权冲动时,公共行政话语所需的并非传统上主导我们领域的行政中立伦理,而是一种宪政伦理,这种伦理借鉴了英国内战时期英国平等派以及随后美国宪法奠基者所阐述的个人虚构。
查看原文摘要
The political fictions used in political discourse, during the English Civil War period, remain relevant to contemporary public policy and administration. Mainstream public administration discourse has too often employed the fiction of a singular and unbounded popular sovereignty that emerged during this period, leaving public administration ill‐equipped to deal with the authoritarian impulses of contemporary populist governments. What is needed in public administration discourse, in dealing with these authoritarian impulses, is not an ethic of administrative neutrality, such as has traditionally dominated much of our field, but an ethic of constitutionalism that draws on the fiction of the individual that was also articulated during the English Civil War period by the English Levellers and subsequently by the founders of the American Constitution.

公共行政与美国民主的危机

Donald F. Kettl

英文原题

Public Administration and the Crisis of American Democracy

公共管理领域正面临真正的危机。美国民众不信任政府及其管理者。当选官员将职业公务员体系攻击为“深层政府”的代理人,尽管承认这一点或许不易,但公共管理的许多批评者所言确有道理。政府的表现往往未能达到公众期望,从业者常常显得对当选官员不够响应,而研究者似乎也只能为从业者提供模糊的指导。然而,公共管理无疑比以往任何时候都更为重要,它承担着将公共目标转化为有效行动,并…

阅读完整摘要 ↗
公共管理领域正面临真正的危机。美国民众不信任政府及其管理者。当选官员将职业公务员体系攻击为“深层政府”的代理人,尽管承认这一点或许不易,但公共管理的许多批评者所言确有道理。政府的表现往往未能达到公众期望,从业者常常显得对当选官员不够响应,而研究者似乎也只能为从业者提供模糊的指导。然而,公共管理无疑比以往任何时候都更为重要,它承担着将公共目标转化为有效行动,并实现麦迪逊及其同僚在建国之初所期望的民主愿景的使命。该领域亟需新的战略与策略,以解决国家面临的新一代难题。通过携手合作,从业者与研究者可以基于这些难题,共同描绘一条激动人心的前进之路。
查看原文摘要
The field of public administration stands amid genuine crisis. Americans don't trust government or its administrators. Elected officials have attacked the career service as agents of the “deep state” and, though it might be hard to admit, many of public administration's critics have a point. Government's performance too often falls short of what people expect, practitioners too often seem too unresponsive to elected officials, and researchers too often seem to have only fuzzy guidance for practitioners. However, public administration undoubtedly is more important now than ever in translating public goals into effective action, and in bringing to life the democratic aspirations Madison and his colleagues wished for the country at its founding. The field urgently needs new strategies and tactics for solving the new generation of puzzles the country faces. In coming together, practitioners and researchers build on these puzzles to chart an exciting road forward.

机构失忆与中央政府机构中“为何理由”的丧失

Alastair Stark, Hridesh Gajurel, Jack Corbett, Dennis C. Grube, Heather Lovell et al.

英文原题

Institutional Amnesia and the Loss of “The Why Rationale” in Central Government Agencies

本文基于对澳大利亚、新西兰及英国威斯敏斯特体系下 115 位官员的访谈数据,证实了制度性失忆与公务员理解其组织环境能力之间存在腐蚀性关系。提出公务员质疑其周围政策、程序及组织框架为何如此的过程,是这种关系运作的一种媒介。随后分析了这种关系及过程产生的四个问题性效应:(1)公务员遵循但不理解程序,(2)无法解释的组织方面被弃置,(3)新组织特征叠加于旧有之上,…

阅读完整摘要 ↗
本文基于对澳大利亚、新西兰及英国威斯敏斯特体系下 115 位官员的访谈数据,证实了制度性失忆与公务员理解其组织环境能力之间存在腐蚀性关系。提出公务员质疑其周围政策、程序及组织框架为何如此的过程,是这种关系运作的一种媒介。随后分析了这种关系及过程产生的四个问题性效应:(1)公务员遵循但不理解程序,(2)无法解释的组织方面被弃置,(3)新组织特征叠加于旧有之上,造成复杂性,以及(4)公共服务效率低下及随之而来的公务员挫败感。文章最后阐述了这一重要关系对公共管理学者及实践者的启示。
查看原文摘要
Data from 115 interviews conducted with officials in the Westminster systems of Australia, New Zealand, and the United Kingdom is used to substantiate a corrosive relationship between institutional amnesia and the ability of public servants to make sense of their organizational context. A process in which public servants question why the policies, procedures, and organizational frameworks that surround them is proposed as one medium through which this relationship operates. Four problematic effects produced by this relationship and process are subsequently analyzed: (1) public servants following but not understanding procedures, (2) inexplicable organizational aspects getting abandoned, (3) the layering of new organizational features on top of old ones, creating complexity, and (4) public service inefficiencies and associated public servant frustration. The article concludes with the implications of this important relationship for public administration scholars and practitioners.

引导与释放:一项安全与司法组织数字化转型 20 年回顾性案例研究的洞见

Friso Selten, Dorus van Loo, Bram Klievink

英文原题

Steering and Setting Free: Insights From a 20‐Year Retrospective Case Study of a Security and Justice Organization's Digital Transformation

数字技术的进步预计将从根本上改变组织的运作方式和价值创造方式。实证研究表明,公共组织在组织和维持这一数字化转型过程中面临诸多困难。为更深入理解这些挑战,本研究考察了过去 20 年间某公共组织数字化转型背后的组织机制。研究发现,这一转型主要依靠涌现式变革路径得以实现,而具有影响力的计划性变革仅偶有发生。我们识别了两种变革类型背后的组织机制,并分析了它们之间的相…

阅读完整摘要 ↗
数字技术的进步预计将从根本上改变组织的运作方式和价值创造方式。实证研究表明,公共组织在组织和维持这一数字化转型过程中面临诸多困难。为更深入理解这些挑战,本研究考察了过去 20 年间某公共组织数字化转型背后的组织机制。研究发现,这一转型主要依靠涌现式变革路径得以实现,而具有影响力的计划性变革仅偶有发生。我们识别了两种变革类型背后的组织机制,并分析了它们之间的相互依存关系。研究结果表明,有效推动公共组织的数字化转型可能既需要涌现式变革,也需要计划性变革,但在实践中将两者结合颇为复杂。
查看原文摘要
Advances in digital technologies are expected to fundamentally change how organizations operate and create value. Empirical studies show that public organizations face difficulties organizing and sustaining this digital transformation. To better understand these challenges, this study examines the organizational mechanisms underlying digital transformation in a public organization over the past 20 years. Our findings show that this transformation was primarily enabled by an emergent change approach, with influential planned changes occurring only occasionally. We identify the organizational mechanisms underlying both types of change and analyze their interdependence. Our findings suggest that both emergent and planned change approaches may be needed to enable digital transformation in public organizations effectively, but that combining them is complex in practice.
JPART 期刊封面

JPART

“看不见也听不见”:承认及其在塑造行政负担中的作用

Noam Tarshish

英文原题

“Unseen and unheard”: Recognition and Its Role in Shaping Administrative Burden

行政负担研究已识别出心理成本与学习成本和合规成本并存,然而该类别仍显同质化,将污名化、自主性削弱和压力等归为一类,却缺乏统一组织原则。本文基于对以色列残疾福利申领的定性案例研究,提出以承认为核心的机制层面解释,该研究通过对 33 名个体(16 名被诊断有心理健康问题的年轻成人和 17 名社会工作者及外展工作人员)的深度访谈展开。我们主张,承认及其被否认是心理…

阅读完整摘要 ↗
行政负担研究已识别出心理成本与学习成本和合规成本并存,然而该类别仍显同质化,将污名化、自主性削弱和压力等归为一类,却缺乏统一组织原则。本文基于对以色列残疾福利申领的定性案例研究,提出以承认为核心的机制层面解释,该研究通过对 33 名个体(16 名被诊断有心理健康问题的年轻成人和 17 名社会工作者及外展工作人员)的深度访谈展开。我们主张,承认及其被否认是心理成本产生机制的一部分,而遭遇是否传递关于个人地位的信息,将该类别区分为三种分析上截然不同的类型。情感成本是对程序负荷的情绪反应,不涉及承认;初级象征成本是对地位定位的情绪反应;次级象征成本则产生于程序负荷本身传递地位信息之时。后两者中承认处于关键地位,通过霍耐特的承认三领域——权利、团结与关怀——加以追溯,每个领域产生其特有的成本配置。这些类型在成因和补救措施上各不相同,情感成本要求效率改革,而象征成本则需以承认为导向的变革。社会工作者作为对抗错误承认的盟友出现,基于这些发现,我们提出官僚承认,即将发声、确定性和验证融入程序设计中,作为针对地位相关成本的补救措施。最后,错误承认既构成象征成本又加剧其他成本,将地位与分配并列,定位为行政负担的关键轴心。
查看原文摘要
Administrative burden scholarship has identified psychological costs alongside learning and compliance costs, yet the category remains homogeneous, grouping stigma, diminished autonomy, and stress, without a shared organizing principle. This article advances a mechanism-level account centered on recognition, drawing on a qualitative case study of claiming disability benefits in Israel, based on in-depth interviews with 33 individuals (16 young adults with diagnosed mental health conditions and 17 social and outreach workers). We argue that recognition, and its denial, are part of the mechanism through which psychological costs are produced, and that whether an encounter carries a message about a person's standing sorts the category into three analytically distinct types. Affective costs are emotional responses to procedural load and involve no recognition; primary symbolic costs are emotional responses to status positioning; and secondary symbolic costs arise when procedural load itself carries a message about standing. The latter two, in which recognition is at stake, are traced through Honneth's three spheres of rights, solidarity, and care, each producing its own configuration of costs. The types differ in their causes and remedies, with affective costs calling for efficiency reforms and symbolic costs for recognition-oriented ones. Social workers emerge as allies who counter misrecognition, and drawing on these findings we propose bureaucratic recognition, the building of voice, certainty, and validation into procedural design, as a remedy for status-related costs. Finally, misrecognition both constitutes symbolic costs and compounds others, positioning status, alongside distribution, as a critical axis of administrative burden.

迈向公共服务动机理论中的“身份转向”:一项问题化综述与研究议程

Lorenza Micacchi, Adrian Ritz

英文原题

Toward an “Identity Turn” in Public Service Motivation Theory: A Problematizing Review and Research Agenda

自公共服务动机(PSM)概念提出以来,它一直被视作公共机构行为的关键驱动力。尽管其重要性显著,质疑之声亦随之浮现。对此,研究主要聚焦于实证分析与测量方法的精炼,而非概念层面的深化发展。这种概念上的路径依赖已渐成问题,因为日益增多的混合实证结果不断挑战 PSM 理论的核心理论命题。我们认为,一个潜在根源在于塑造该领域的主导假设:即其在动机理论中的定位。为应对此…

阅读完整摘要 ↗
自公共服务动机(PSM)概念提出以来,它一直被视作公共机构行为的关键驱动力。尽管其重要性显著,质疑之声亦随之浮现。对此,研究主要聚焦于实证分析与测量方法的精炼,而非概念层面的深化发展。这种概念上的路径依赖已渐成问题,因为日益增多的混合实证结果不断挑战 PSM 理论的核心理论命题。我们认为,一个潜在根源在于塑造该领域的主导假设:即其在动机理论中的定位。为应对此问题,我们开展了一项跨概念、跨学科的批判性审视,比较了公共行政领域对 PSM 的理解与管理学、心理学、社会学及经济学中相关概念(如动机、利他主义和身份认同)的异同。基于此分析,我们提出一个新颖的理论框架,将 PSM 重新概念化为一种社会身份认同。据此,我们勾勒出一项研究议程,该议程:(i)修订 PSM 的核心概念特征,并基于身份认同理论开发新的测量方法;(ii)引入身份工作理论,以全新视角理解 PSM 的作用机制;(iii)将 PSM 理论置于动机研究中“身份转向”的更广泛讨论中,凸显其对该多学科对话的潜在贡献。
查看原文摘要
Since its inception, Public Service Motivation (PSM) has been recognized as a key driver of behavior in public institutions. Despite its prominence, skepticism has emerged. In response, research has primarily focused on empirical analysis and measurement refinement rather than on conceptual development. This conceptual path dependency has become problematic as mixed empirical results increasingly challenge core theoretical propositions of PSM theory. We argue that one potential cause lies in a dominant assumption shaping the field: its positioning within motivation theory. To address this, we conducted a problematizing review across concepts and disciplines, comparing how PSM is understood in Public Administration with related concepts–such as motivation, altruism, and identity–in Management, Psychology, Sociology, and Economics. Based on this analysis, we propose a novel theoretical framework that reconceptualizes PSM as a social identity. In doing so, we outline a research agenda that (i) revises PSM’s core conceptual features and develops a new measurement approach informed by identity theory; (ii) introduces new ways of understanding PSM's functioning through identity work theory; and (iii) situates PSM theory within the broader debate on the “identity turn” in motivation research, highlighting its potential contribution to this multidisciplinary discourse.

客户财务资源、心理健康及动机对一线工作者负担减轻与优先级排序的影响

Niels Bjørn Grund Petersen, Jonas Krogh Madsen

英文原题

The effect of clients’ financial resources, mental health, and motivation on frontline workers’ burden reduction and prioritizations

街头官僚文献表明,一线工作者对客户的决策受到基于客户人口统计特征和行为表现的应得性认知的影响。然而,尽管行政负担文献将财务资源和心理健康视为公民体验合规要求时的两个核心因素,我们对于一线工作者是否也会依据客户的财务资源和心理健康采取行动知之甚少。我们通过开发和测试预先注册的假设,为这两类文献做出贡献,这些假设考察了客户财务资源和心理健康信息如何影响一线工作者…

阅读完整摘要 ↗
街头官僚文献表明,一线工作者对客户的决策受到基于客户人口统计特征和行为表现的应得性认知的影响。然而,尽管行政负担文献将财务资源和心理健康视为公民体验合规要求时的两个核心因素,我们对于一线工作者是否也会依据客户的财务资源和心理健康采取行动知之甚少。我们通过开发和测试预先注册的假设,为这两类文献做出贡献,这些假设考察了客户财务资源和心理健康信息如何影响一线工作者的负担减轻和客户优先排序。为此,我们在丹麦三十九个失业机构中,对 775 名个案工作者进行了一项大规模的情景实验,操纵了客户的年龄、财务状况、心理健康和动机,但保持性别不变(所有客户均为男性)。我们发现强有力的证据表明,个案工作者会减轻负担并优先考虑有心理健康问题的客户,并且与先前研究一致,优先考虑表现出高动机的客户,同时也有部分证据表明他们会支持面临经济困难的客户。重要的是,心理健康似乎比动机和财务资源更具影响力。与我们预先注册的预期相反,有心理健康问题的客户在同时表现出低动机而非高动机时获得了最多的支持。这一模式并非表明一线工作者奖励低动机,而更可能反映了个案工作者将低动机解释为潜在疾病的症状,从而视为更大需求的信号。我们的研究结果表明,一线自由裁量权可以作为一种再分配机制运作,将支持导向那些表现出最大需求的客户。
查看原文摘要
The street-level bureaucracy literature shows that frontline workers’ decisions about clients are shaped by perceptions of deservingness based on clients’ demographic characteristics and behavioral conduct. Yet, we know little about whether frontline workers also act on clients’ financial resources and mental health, despite the administrative burden literature identifying these two factors as central to how citizens experience compliance demands. We contribute to both literatures by developing and testing preregistered hypotheses that examine how information about clients’ financial resources and mental health shapes frontline workers’ burden reduction and client prioritization. To do this, we run a large-scale vignette experiment with 775 caseworkers across thirty-nine Danish unemployment agencies, manipulating client age, financial situation, mental health, and motivation but holding gender constant (all clients were male). We find strong evidence that caseworkers reduce burdens and prioritize clients with mental health issues and—consistent with prior work—clients displaying high motivation, alongside some evidence for clients struggling with financial hardship. Importantly, mental health appears more consequential than motivation and financial resources. Contrary to our preregistered expectation, clients with mental health issues received the most support when they also displayed low as opposed to high motivation. Rather than indicating that frontline workers reward low motivation, this pattern most likely reflects that caseworkers interpret low motivation as a symptom of the underlying condition and thus as a signal of greater need. Our findings show how frontline discretion can operate as a redistributive mechanism that channels support toward clients signaling the greatest need.

每一英里都算数:知识产权服务中作为行政负担的地理距离

Shenghua Lu

英文原题

Every Mile Counts: Geographical Distance as Administrative Burden in Intellectual Property Services

尽管已有研究探讨了行政负担的程序性和信息性来源,本文则考察行政权力的地理配置这一组织设计选择如何将空间负担制度化为企业面临的障碍。我们利用中国商标注册服务中的 decentralization 改革作为自然实验来检验这一理论。该改革通过 2016 年至 2019 年间在全国设立地方受理窗口,缩短了地理距离。改革前,商标申请必须统一提交至北京中央办公室,对全国…

阅读完整摘要 ↗
尽管已有研究探讨了行政负担的程序性和信息性来源,本文则考察行政权力的地理配置这一组织设计选择如何将空间负担制度化为企业面临的障碍。我们利用中国商标注册服务中的 decentralization 改革作为自然实验来检验这一理论。该改革通过 2016 年至 2019 年间在全国设立地方受理窗口,缩短了地理距离。改革前,商标申请必须统一提交至北京中央办公室,对全国企业构成了重大的地理障碍。利用涵盖中国 294 个城市超过 3700 万件商标申请的独特数据集,我们采用交错双重差分法来估计地理距离缩短对商标申请的因果效应。研究发现,设立地方受理窗口使商标申请量增加了约 4.4%,仅 2019 年就新增约 20.9 万件申请。此外,该改革产生了复合性的分配效应:中小企业的反应强于大型企业,且新进入商标体系的企业集中于基础设施较为薄弱的城市。机制分析证实,这一增长主要由距离缩短驱动,而非行政效率提升或腐败减少所致。本研究为行政服务跨空间重新配置的行为后果提供了大规模因果证据,表明即使在行政服务数字化转型的背景下,物理可及性对于服务的公平获取仍至关重要。
查看原文摘要
While existing research has examined procedural and informational sources of administrative burden, this paper examines how organizational design choices about the geographic location of administrative authority institutionalize spatial burdens on firms. We leverage China's decentralization reform in trademark registration services as a natural experiment to test this theory. This reform reduced geographic distance by establishing local acceptance windows across the country from 2016 to 2019. Prior to this reform, trademark applications had to be submitted exclusively at the centralized Beijing office, imposing substantial geographic barriers on firms nationwide. Using a unique dataset covering over 37 million trademark applications from 294 Chinese cities, we employ a staggered difference-in-differences approach to estimate the causal effects of reduced geographic distance on trademark filings. We find that establishing local acceptance windows increased trademark applications by approximately 4.4 percent, or roughly 209,000 additional filings in 2019 alone. Moreover, the reform generated compound distributional outcomes: small and medium-sized enterprises responded more strongly than larger firms, and the new applicants drawn into the trademark system were concentrated in cities with thinner infrastructure. Mechanism analysis confirms that this increase is primarily driven by distance reduction rather than improvements in administrative efficiency or reductions in corruption. The findings provide large-scale causal evidence on the behavioral consequences of redistributing administrative service delivery across space, demonstrating that physical accessibility remains crucial for equitable service uptake even amid the digital transformation of administrative services.

厌倦变化?挪威幼儿园所有权转换后的病假缺勤情况

Håvard Thorsen Rydland, Dag Arne Christensen

英文原题

Sick of change? Sickness absence following ownership conversions in Norwegian kindergartens

混合提供者福利体系的扩张加剧了关于公共、非营利及营利性提供后果的争论。现有研究主要聚焦于效率、服务质量和公民结果,而对所有权转换对员工影响的了解相对较少。我们基于研究表明,所有权转换可能扰乱员工与组织之间的价值一致性,并改变激励机制。利用挪威儿童保育服务(2015-2019 年)的全人口行政数据,我们考察了所有权转换是否与员工病假缺勤的变化相关。采用交错双重…

阅读完整摘要 ↗
混合提供者福利体系的扩张加剧了关于公共、非营利及营利性提供后果的争论。现有研究主要聚焦于效率、服务质量和公民结果,而对所有权转换对员工影响的了解相对较少。我们基于研究表明,所有权转换可能扰乱员工与组织之间的价值一致性,并改变激励机制。利用挪威儿童保育服务(2015-2019 年)的全人口行政数据,我们考察了所有权转换是否与员工病假缺勤的变化相关。采用交错双重差分设计,我们发现非营利向营利转换后病假缺勤有所增加。同时,公共向营利过渡与病假缺勤之间几乎没有一致的关系。这些发现表明,员工对所有权变化的反应更多受组织使命和价值观差异的影响,而非公私分野。更广泛地,本研究强调了组织价值一致性作为连接所有权安排与员工福祉的潜在机制,并提示非营利与营利之间的界限可能比传统的公私分野对员工更具实质性影响。
查看原文摘要
The expansion of mixed-provider welfare systems has intensified debates about the consequences of public, nonprofit, and for-profit provision. Existing research focuses primarily on efficiency, service quality, and citizens’ outcomes, while less is known about ownership conversions’ consequences for employees. We depart from research suggesting that ownership conversions can disrupt employee-organization value congruence as well as change the incentive structures. Leveraging population-wide administrative data from Norwegian childcare services (2015–2019), we examine whether ownership conversions are associated with changes in employee sickness absence. Using a staggered difference-in-differences design, we find that sickness absence increases following nonprofit-to-for-profit conversions. At the same time, public-to-for-profit transitions show little consistent relationship with sickness absence. These findings suggest that employee responses to ownership change are shaped less by the public–private divide than by differences in organizational missions and values. More broadly, the study highlights organizational value congruence as a potential mechanism linking ownership arrangements to employee well-being, and suggests that the nonprofit-for-profit boundary may be more consequential for employees than the conventional public–private divide.
Governance 期刊封面

Governance

协调相互竞争的期望——酋长与加纳矿产治理

Joel Agbesinyale

英文原题

Negotiating Competing Expectations—Chiefs and Mineral Governance in Ghana

本文探讨了在混合治理安排下,酋长 discretionary 决策的塑造因素及其行使权力的方式,重点关注加纳的手工和小规模采矿(ASM)部门。现有学术研究认识到传统权威可以加强或削弱国家治理,但对其实践差异的解释有限。基于对酋长、矿工和国家官员的访谈,本文构建了一个融合混合治理、获取理论与自由裁量权的 discretionary 治理框架。文章认为,重叠的习…

阅读完整摘要 ↗
本文探讨了在混合治理安排下,酋长 discretionary 决策的塑造因素及其行使权力的方式,重点关注加纳的手工和小规模采矿(ASM)部门。现有学术研究认识到传统权威可以加强或削弱国家治理,但对其实践差异的解释有限。基于对酋长、矿工和国家官员的访谈,本文构建了一个融合混合治理、获取理论与自由裁量权的 discretionary 治理框架。文章认为,重叠的习惯法与法定权威为酋长创造了一个自由裁量空间,使其能够在相互竞争的期望中周旋。酋长通过多样化的治理实践行使这种自由裁量权,包括限制矿区准入、动员社区、与国家机构合作,以及促进土地获取、协商非正式支付和保护未经授权的矿工免受执法。这些实践可能强化、协商、规避或削弱正式的采矿监管。本文推进了关于传统权威与混合治理的辩论,同时挑战了宪法赋权酋长必然加强矿产治理的假设。
查看原文摘要
This paper examines what shapes chiefs' discretionary decision‐making and how they exercise authority within hybrid governance arrangements, focusing on Ghana's artisanal and small‐scale mining (ASM) sector. Existing scholarship recognizes that traditional authorities can strengthen or undermine state governance but offers limited explanations for variation in their practices. Drawing on interviews with chiefs, miners, and state officials, the paper develops a discretionary governance framework that integrates hybrid governance, access theory, and discretion. It argues that overlapping customary and statutory authority creates a discretionary space for chiefs to navigate competing expectations. Chiefs exercise this discretion through diverse governance practices, including restricting access to mining sites, mobilizing communities, and collaborating with state institutions, as well as facilitating access to land, negotiating informal payments, and shielding unauthorised miners from enforcement. These practices can reinforce, negotiate, circumvent, or undermine formal mining regulation. The paper advances debates on traditional authority and hybrid governance while challenging assumptions that constitutionally empowering chiefs necessarily strengthens mineral governance.

效仿领导者?解释加拿大联邦体制中的危机政策变革

Liddell Hastings

英文原题

Emulate the Leader? Explaining Crisis Policy Change in the Canadian Federal System

在危机时期,政府是会协调行动,还是各自独立决策而不顾他国所为?疫情初期,联邦制国家中新冠政策的趋同现象已被广泛研究。然而,关于何种机制使得各辖区间政策如此相似的研究却相对有限。借助加拿大分散化的联邦体系,本文提出,这种趋同可以通过政策扩散过程中的模仿机制及一系列领导者-追随者关系来解释。基于政策扩散文献,本文提出三个假设,解释为何某些辖区在危机政策中扮演领导…

阅读完整摘要 ↗
在危机时期,政府是会协调行动,还是各自独立决策而不顾他国所为?疫情初期,联邦制国家中新冠政策的趋同现象已被广泛研究。然而,关于何种机制使得各辖区间政策如此相似的研究却相对有限。借助加拿大分散化的联邦体系,本文提出,这种趋同可以通过政策扩散过程中的模仿机制及一系列领导者-追随者关系来解释。基于政策扩散文献,本文提出三个假设,解释为何某些辖区在危机政策中扮演领导角色,而其他辖区则选择跟随。这些假设被综合为邻近性、能力与紧迫性,并通过一系列成对向量自回归模型进行检验,以识别加拿大各省间显著的领导者-追随者关系。研究结果表明,政策主要源自少数大省(魁北克与安大略),这为所提假设提供了部分证据,但也存在例外情况。
查看原文摘要
In times of crises, do governments coordinate or do they make their own choices independent of what others do? Convergence of COVID‐19 policy at the beginning of the pandemic has been widely studied in federal countries. Yet, there is limited literature looking at the mechanisms that made policy between jurisdictions so similar. Utilizing Canada's decentralized federal system, this paper posits that convergence can be explained by a process of policy diffusion through emulation and a series of leader‐follower relationships. Drawing on the policy diffusion literature, this paper proposes three hypotheses for why some jurisdictions take on leadership roles in crisis policy while others follow. Synthesized as proximity, capacity, and urgency, these hypotheses are tested using a series of pairwise vector autoregressions identifying significant leader‐follower relationships between Canadian provinces. The findings suggest that policy primarily flowed from only a small number of large provinces (Quebec and Ontario), lending partial evidence, but also exceptions to the hypotheses proposed.

永生悖论:一党主导、政治任期与日本行政机构的组织延续性

Ayako Nakamura

英文原题

The Immortality Paradox: One‐Party Dominance, Political Tenure, and Organizational Continuity in Japanese Agencies

在 1976 年关于组织生存的经典研究中,Kaufman 提出公共组织是“不朽的”。然而,近期的研究得出了相反的结论,发现公共组织频繁被终止。这些发现主要与执政党定期更迭的背景相关。相比之下,本研究考察了日本政府机构的生存情况,该国战后政治体系以一党独大和短暂的政治领导为特征。研究结果表明,日本机构在很大程度上仍保持“不朽”,即便发生转型,也往往与任期较长的…

阅读完整摘要 ↗
在 1976 年关于组织生存的经典研究中,Kaufman 提出公共组织是“不朽的”。然而,近期的研究得出了相反的结论,发现公共组织频繁被终止。这些发现主要与执政党定期更迭的背景相关。相比之下,本研究考察了日本政府机构的生存情况,该国战后政治体系以一党独大和短暂的政治领导为特征。研究结果表明,日本机构在很大程度上仍保持“不朽”,即便发生转型,也往往与任期较长的首相有关,他们能够实施次要的、表面性的变革;因此,即使经历此类事件,机构通常依然存续。本研究因此为政治-行政关系如何塑造机构转型模式提供了新的视角,并强调了领导任期在维持组织变革承诺中的重要性。
查看原文摘要
In his classic 1976 study on organizational survival, Kaufman argued that public organizations are “immortal”. More recent research, however, has come to the opposite conclusion, finding that public organizations are frequently terminated. These findings largely relate to contexts where changes to the ruling party occur regularly. In contrast, this study examines the survival of government agencies in Japan, where the postwar political system has been characterized by one‐party dominance and short‐lived political leadership. The findings suggest that Japanese agencies remain largely “immortal,” and that when they do undergo transitions this tends to be linked to prime ministers with longer tenures who are able to implement minor, cosmetic changes; hence agencies typically persist even after such events. This study thus sheds new light on how political–administrative relations shape patterns of agency transition and highlights the importance of leadership tenure in sustaining commitments to organizational change.

民粹主义执政下的监管机构变迁:来自意大利的洞见(1990-2025)

Fabrizio Di Mascio, Giulio Francisci, Martino Maggetti, Alessandro Natalini

英文原题

Regulatory Agencies Under Mutating Populism in Office: Insights From Italy (1990–2025)

我们的论文在民粹主义治理下的公共行政这一新兴研究领域与关于独立监管机构(IRAs)授权的既有文献之间架起了一座桥梁。我们聚焦于意大利,这是西欧的一个关键案例,在 2001 年至 2025 年间,该国经历了六届由不同意识形态取向的民粹主义政党主导或强烈影响的联合政府。研究结果表明,一旦制度化,向 IRAs 的授权即使在持续的政治争议下也表现出显著的韧性。尽管自…

阅读完整摘要 ↗
我们的论文在民粹主义治理下的公共行政这一新兴研究领域与关于独立监管机构(IRAs)授权的既有文献之间架起了一座桥梁。我们聚焦于意大利,这是西欧的一个关键案例,在 2001 年至 2025 年间,该国经历了六届由不同意识形态取向的民粹主义政党主导或强烈影响的联合政府。研究结果表明,一旦制度化,向 IRAs 的授权即使在持续的政治争议下也表现出显著的韧性。尽管自 21 世纪初以来民粹主义政党屡次参与执政,意大利的 IRAs 并未遭受系统性的去授权或法定缩减。然而,正式独立性的保留并不意味着缺乏政治控制的手段。我们的分析显示,民粹主义政府系统性地依赖政治任命。有趣的是,这些政治任命并非由党派忠诚或公开的政治化所驱动。相反,民粹主义政党的干预沿着授权理论中较少受到关注的政治控制维度运作:被任命者的专业化程度。民粹主义政府倾向于任命领域专业化水平较低的 IRAs 董事会成员,偏好通才型人物而非专家型人才。
查看原文摘要
Our paper builds a bridge between the emerging strand of research on public administration under populist rule and the established literature on delegation to independent regulatory authorities (IRAs). We focus on Italy, a critical case in Western Europe, which between 2001 and 2025 experienced six coalition governments dominated or strongly influenced by populist parties of different ideological orientations. Findings highlight that delegation to IRAs is remarkably resilient once institutionalized, even under sustained political contestation. Despite repeated populist participation in government since the early 2000s, Italian IRAs have not been subject to systematic de‐delegation or statutory retrenchment. However, the preservation of formal independence has not implied the absence of means for political control. Our analysis shows that populist governments have systematically relied on political appointments. Interestingly, political appointments have not been driven by partisan loyalty or overt politicization. Instead, the intervention of populist parties has operated along a different dimension of political control that has received less attention in delegation theory: the specialization of appointees. Populist governments have displayed a preference for appointing IRAs' board members with lower levels of domain‐specific specialization, privileging generalist profiles over specialists.

中国实验治理中的死胡同与政策变迁

Vincent Brussee

英文原题

Dead Ends and Policy Change in Chinese Experimental Governance

并非所有政策变迁都是扩张性的,然而非扩张性轨迹仍未得到充分研究。本文引入了“死胡同”这一概念:即政策过程中,倡议在现有形式下停止发展或实施,从而构建后续政策变迁(如回退、转向或终止)的阶段。为考察此类轨迹,本文结合了对 2013 年至 2018 年间中华人民共和国宣布的 27,103 项政策实验的大规模分析与定性案例研究。研究发现,绝大多数实验——高达 90…

阅读完整摘要 ↗
并非所有政策变迁都是扩张性的,然而非扩张性轨迹仍未得到充分研究。本文引入了“死胡同”这一概念:即政策过程中,倡议在现有形式下停止发展或实施,从而构建后续政策变迁(如回退、转向或终止)的阶段。为考察此类轨迹,本文结合了对 2013 年至 2018 年间中华人民共和国宣布的 27,103 项政策实验的大规模分析与定性案例研究。研究发现,绝大多数实验——高达 90%——最终陷入死胡同。这些死胡同与领导层更迭、政策复杂性以及与官僚激励机制和社会经济条件的不匹配相关联。总体而言,本文为理解政策变迁的替代方向提供了新框架。同时,也对中国治理体系的适应能力与结构性约束提供了新的洞见。
查看原文摘要
Not all policy change is expansive, yet non‐expansive trajectories remain underexamined. This article introduces the concept of dead ends: a stage of the policy process in which initiatives cease to develop or be implemented in their existing form, structuring subsequent policy change such as rollback, redirection, or termination. To examine such trajectories, the article combines large‐scale analysis of 27,103 policy experiments announced in the People's Republic of China between 2013 and 2018 with qualitative case studies. The findings suggest that a substantial majority—up to 90%—of experiments reach dead ends. These dead ends are associated with leadership turnover, policy complexity, and misalignment with bureaucratic incentives and socio‐economic conditions. Altogether, the article provides new frameworks for understanding alternative directions of policy change. In doing so, it also sheds new light on the adaptive capacity and structural constraints of China's governance system.
Public Management Review 期刊封面

Public Management Review

Policy Studies Journal 期刊封面

Policy Studies Journal

政策设计与极化:政策特征如何调节议题极化与社会极化之间的关系

Johnathan Noah Wolff, Deven E. Carlson, Adam Tyner

英文原题

Policy Design and Polarization: How Policy Characteristics Moderate the Relationship Between Issue and Social Polarization

政治学家区分基于议题的两极分化(即政策偏好上的党派差异)与基于身份的两极分化(即不同身份个体之间的社会敌意,无论政治身份与否),并已证明后者能推动前者的加剧。我们通过探讨政策特征是否调节基于身份的两极分化导致议题两极分化的程度,来拓展这一研究。我们借鉴先前研究,识别出三大类别的七项政策特征(政策不确定性、政策广度及政策熟悉度),这些特征综合起来,决定了基于身…

阅读完整摘要 ↗
政治学家区分基于议题的两极分化(即政策偏好上的党派差异)与基于身份的两极分化(即不同身份个体之间的社会敌意,无论政治身份与否),并已证明后者能推动前者的加剧。我们通过探讨政策特征是否调节基于身份的两极分化导致议题两极分化的程度,来拓展这一研究。我们借鉴先前研究,识别出三大类别的七项政策特征(政策不确定性、政策广度及政策熟悉度),这些特征综合起来,决定了基于身份的两极分化围绕该政策引发议题两极分化的可能性。我们对此命题的实证评估基于两项独立调查的数据,这些调查询问了受访者对三个不同教育政策议题的看法:社会情感学习、批判性种族理论及平权行动。与我们的预期一致,三个政策领域的结果均显示,在具备这些特征的政策上,基于身份的支持差距显著大于缺乏这些特征的政策上的支持差距。
查看原文摘要
Political scientists distinguish between issue‐based polarization (i.e., partisan differences in policy preferences) and identity‐based polarization (i.e., social animus between individuals with different identities, political or otherwise) and have shown that the latter can drive increases in the former. We extend this work by exploring whether policy characteristics moderate the extent to which identity‐based polarization leads to issue polarization. We draw on prior research to identify seven policy characteristics across three broad categories (policy uncertainty, policy breadth, and policy familiarity) that, when combined, shape the likelihood of identity‐based polarization driving issue polarization around the policy. Our empirical assessment of this proposition draws on data from two separate surveys that polled respondents about their views on three different education policy topics: Social and Emotional Learning, Critical Race Theory, and affirmative action. Consistent with our expectations, results across each of the three policy areas show that identity‐based gaps in support for policies that exhibit these characteristics are substantially larger than support gaps around policies where these characteristics are absent.

证据使用中的波动性:间断均衡理论的计算机分析

Stefani Langehennig

英文原题

Volatility in Evidence Use: A Computational Analysis of Punctuated Equilibrium Theory

政策文件中证据的使用如何随时间变化,以及如何解释其使用中稳定、渐进与突变之间的差异?本研究引入了一个计算框架,用以评估美国国会研究服务处(CRS)报告中证据使用的变化。通过结合大语言模型与监督式机器学习,每份文件依据其与循证决策原则的契合度进行评分,并在政策主题层面进行汇总。结果显示,大多数政策领域呈现渐进式变化,而突变式转变则较为少见且高度多变。公众关注度…

阅读完整摘要 ↗
政策文件中证据的使用如何随时间变化,以及如何解释其使用中稳定、渐进与突变之间的差异?本研究引入了一个计算框架,用以评估美国国会研究服务处(CRS)报告中证据使用的变化。通过结合大语言模型与监督式机器学习,每份文件依据其与循证决策原则的契合度进行评分,并在政策主题层面进行汇总。结果显示,大多数政策领域呈现渐进式变化,而突变式转变则较为少见且高度多变。公众关注度与证据使用的突变轨迹相关,而媒体和行政部门的关注主要与渐进式变化相关;在考虑关注度和制度需求后,党派控制的作用有限。各政策主题之间仍存在显著差异,其中宏观经济学和政府运作等领域在证据使用评分上表现出相对较高的离散度。这些发现表明,政策制定中的证据使用是动态的,且随时间推移对关注度敏感。
查看原文摘要
How does the use of evidence in policy documents change over time, and what explains differences between stable, incremental, and abrupt shifts in its use? This study introduces a computational framework to evaluate change in evidence use across Congressional Research Service (CRS) reports. Using a combination of large language models and supervised machine learning, each document is scored on its alignment with evidence‐based policymaking principles and aggregated to the policy‐topic level. The results show that most policy areas exhibit gradual change, while punctuated shifts are less common and highly variable. Public salience is associated with punctuated evidence‐use trajectories, while media and executive attention are associated primarily with gradual change; partisan control plays a limited role once attention and institutional demand are taken into account. Substantial variation remains across policy topics, with areas such as Macroeconomics and Government Operations exhibiting relatively high dispersion in evidence‐use scores. These findings demonstrate that evidence use in policymaking is dynamic and attention‐sensitive over time.

当更多即是更多:委员会重叠与问题界定中的信息多样性

Connor Dye

英文原题

When More Is More: Committee Overlap and the Diversity of Information in Problem Definition

国会依赖分散的官僚体系来监控复杂问题,这引发了对它能否整合有效决策所需多样化信息的担忧。我认为,与机构有不同制度联系的委员会之间的竞争,无需任何协调机构即可产生信息多样性。通过分析 1973 年至 2021 年间 131 个机构的 92,375 次机构证词实例,我发现,审查某一问题的委员会数量越多,提供信息的机构范围就越广泛且集中度越低。几乎没有证据表明这种…

阅读完整摘要 ↗
国会依赖分散的官僚体系来监控复杂问题,这引发了对它能否整合有效决策所需多样化信息的担忧。我认为,与机构有不同制度联系的委员会之间的竞争,无需任何协调机构即可产生信息多样性。通过分析 1973 年至 2021 年间 131 个机构的 92,375 次机构证词实例,我发现,审查某一问题的委员会数量越多,提供信息的机构范围就越广泛且集中度越低。几乎没有证据表明这种关联会受到公众关注度的系统性调节。
查看原文摘要
Congress relies on a fragmented bureaucracy to monitor complex problems, raising concerns over whether it can aggregate the diverse information needed for effective policy‐making. I argue that competition among committees with different institutional ties to agencies should produce informational diversity without any coordinating body. Analyzing 92,375 instances of agency testimony across 131 agencies from 1973 to 2021, I find that a greater number of committees examining a problem is consistently associated with a broader and less concentrated set of agencies supplying information. I find little evidence that this association is systematically moderated by public salience.

议程设置中的游说优先事项:经济团体与公民团体在议程广度、方向及回应性上的差异

Frederik Stevens, Darren Halpin

英文原题

Lobbying Priorities in Agenda‐Setting: Agenda Breadth, Direction, and Responsiveness Across Economic and Citizen Groups

利益集团是塑造政治议程的关键行动者。然而,我们对它们在政策过程的最初阶段如何确定游说优先事项知之甚少。本研究提出了一种新颖的概念框架,用于在议程设定阶段研究利益集团的问题优先排序,该框架涵盖三个互补维度:议程广度、议程方向和议程响应性。基于对 630 个欧盟层面利益集团的原始调查数据,我们的结果表明,问题优先排序主要由集团所代表的成员类型驱动。经济利益集团倾…

阅读完整摘要 ↗
利益集团是塑造政治议程的关键行动者。然而,我们对它们在政策过程的最初阶段如何确定游说优先事项知之甚少。本研究提出了一种新颖的概念框架,用于在议程设定阶段研究利益集团的问题优先排序,该框架涵盖三个互补维度:议程广度、议程方向和议程响应性。基于对 630 个欧盟层面利益集团的原始调查数据,我们的结果表明,问题优先排序主要由集团所代表的成员类型驱动。经济利益集团倾向于追求更广泛的游说议程,专注于维护政策现状,并在优先处理不受欢迎的问题时更响应内部成员压力。相比之下,公民团体通常采取更狭窄的议程,优先挑战现状,并在确定游说优先事项时更强烈地响应外部问题显著性。总体而言,本研究增进了我们对利益集团如何在政治注意力竞争中导航的理解,并为当代民主国家中关于议程设定的更广泛辩论做出了贡献。
查看原文摘要
Interest groups are key actors in shaping political agendas. Yet, we know surprisingly little about how they determine their lobbying priorities at the earliest stage of the policy process. This study advances a novel conceptual framework for studying interest groups' issue prioritization in the agenda setting stage along three complementary dimensions: agenda breadth, agenda direction, and agenda responsiveness. Drawing on original survey data from 630 EU level interest groups, our results show that issue prioritization is driven primarily by the type of constituents a group represents. Economic interest groups tend to pursue broader lobbying agendas, focus on defending the policy status quo, and are more responsive to internal member pressures when prioritizing undesired issues. Citizen groups, by contrast, typically adopt narrower agendas, prioritize challenging the status quo, and respond more strongly to external issue salience when determining their lobbying priorities. Overall, the study advances our understanding of how interest groups navigate competition for political attention and contributes to broader debates on agenda‐setting in contemporary democracies.

人口老龄化与公民对自动化和移民的偏好:对高度老龄化经济体的警示?

Sijeong Lim, Seiki Tanaka

英文原题

Population Aging and Citizen Preferences for Automation and Immigration: A Cautionary Tale for Advanced Aging Economies?

大量研究凸显了公众对移民和机器人的担忧,但很少有研究探讨人口结构挑战,特别是人口老龄化,如何影响这些看法。公众在评估移民或自动化政策时,可能不会自然而然地考虑到人口老龄化,因为这些议题往往被孤立讨论。因此,我们假设,若引导公众考虑人口老龄化,他们将更倾向于支持自动化和移民。通过在日本、韩国和法国三个国家进行的预注册调查实验,我们探究了提供关于人口老龄化的客观…

阅读完整摘要 ↗
大量研究凸显了公众对移民和机器人的担忧,但很少有研究探讨人口结构挑战,特别是人口老龄化,如何影响这些看法。公众在评估移民或自动化政策时,可能不会自然而然地考虑到人口老龄化,因为这些议题往往被孤立讨论。因此,我们假设,若引导公众考虑人口老龄化,他们将更倾向于支持自动化和移民。通过在日本、韩国和法国三个国家进行的预注册调查实验,我们探究了提供关于人口老龄化的客观信息是否会改变对移民和自动化的态度。研究发现,在日本——全球老龄化最严重的国家,此类信息促使人们对移民和自动化都产生更积极的态度。在韩国——老龄化速度最快的国家,此类信息仅改善了人们对移民的态度。而在法国,其老年人口比例处于欧盟平均水平,我们未发现显著影响。然而,我们发现,在日本和韩国,当受访者将自动化和移民政策与其他选项(如调整退休年龄)一并考虑时,这些积极效应并未持续。这些发现表明,公众对人口老龄化回应的政策偏好受制于国家特定情境,以及政策讨论中被激活的不同议题关联。
查看原文摘要
Extensive research highlights public apprehension toward immigrants and robots, but few studies examine how demographic challenges, particularly population aging, influence these perceptions. The public may not naturally consider population aging when evaluating immigration or automation policies, as these issues are often discussed in silos. We thus hypothesize that priming the public to consider population aging will lead them to view automation and immigration more favorably. Using pre‐registered survey experiments in three countries—Japan, South Korea, and France—we investigate whether providing factual information about population aging alters attitudes toward immigration and automation. We find that in Japan, the world's most aged country, such information generates more favorable attitudes toward both immigration and automation. In Korea, the fastest‐aging country, it improves only immigration attitudes. In France, where the elderly population is average for the EU, we find no significant effect. We find, however, that these positive effects in Japan and Korea do not persist when respondents consider automation and immigration policies alongside other options like adjusting the retirement age. These findings suggest that the public's policy preferences in response to population aging are subject to country‐specific contexts, as well as to different issue linkages activated in policy discussions.
Am. Review of Public Admin 期刊封面

Am. Review of Public Admin

地方自治、地方自主权与选民:解释政府增长

Siân Mughan, Huiyuan Wu

英文原题

Home Rule, Local Autonomy, and Voters: Explaining Government Growth

本文通过分析市政当局对税收自主权增加的反应,以及这些反应是否受选民偏好制约,来考察地方政府的增长。具体而言,我们研究了当转向地方自治地位(HRS)与选民偏好无关时,以及当选民采纳地方自治时,地方自治的财政影响。我们发现,当 HRS 的变化与选民偏好无关时,地方自治对税收征收没有影响。然而,税收结构会转向更贴近中位选民偏好的形态。相反,当选民选择进入 HRS …

阅读完整摘要 ↗
本文通过分析市政当局对税收自主权增加的反应,以及这些反应是否受选民偏好制约,来考察地方政府的增长。具体而言,我们研究了当转向地方自治地位(HRS)与选民偏好无关时,以及当选民采纳地方自治时,地方自治的财政影响。我们发现,当 HRS 的变化与选民偏好无关时,地方自治对税收征收没有影响。然而,税收结构会转向更贴近中位选民偏好的形态。相反,当选民选择进入 HRS 时,税收收入会出现显著且持续的上升,这主要由财产税和销售税的增加所驱动。这些发现表明,地方财政政策对中位选民的偏好具有响应性。
查看原文摘要
This paper examines local government growth by analyzing how municipalities respond to increases in taxing autonomy and whether their responses are conditioned on voter preferences. Specifically, we investigate the fiscal impact of home rule when the shift to home rule status (HRS) is independent of voter preferences versus when voters adopt home rule. We find that home rule has no effect on tax collections when changes in HRS are unrelated to voter preferences. However, the tax structure shifts to one that more closely aligns with the preferences of the median voter. In contrast, when voters select into HRS there is a significant and sustained increase in tax revenues that is driven by increases in property and sales taxes. These findings indicate that local fiscal policy is responsive to the preferences of the median voter.

理解地方政府中的人工智能采纳:能力限制还是政治谨慎?

Yung-Yu Tsai, Lael Keiser, Niki Jabbari

英文原题

Understanding AI Adoption in Local Government: Capacity Constraints or Political Caution?

人工智能(AI)已被各国政府广泛采用,但各政府是否采用及采用程度存在差异。一个关键问题是,地方政府间 AI 采用差异是否源于能力差异或政治约束。理解这一点对于官员可能希望采取何种政策以确保地方政府获得所需且必要的技术具有重要意义。本文结合国际城市/县管理协会(ICMA)调查、美国趋势小组(ATP)、当前人口调查(CPS)及其他公共数据源的数据,考察了能力与政…

阅读完整摘要 ↗
人工智能(AI)已被各国政府广泛采用,但各政府是否采用及采用程度存在差异。一个关键问题是,地方政府间 AI 采用差异是否源于能力差异或政治约束。理解这一点对于官员可能希望采取何种政策以确保地方政府获得所需且必要的技术具有重要意义。本文结合国际城市/县管理协会(ICMA)调查、美国趋势小组(ATP)、当前人口调查(CPS)及其他公共数据源的数据,考察了能力与政治约束如何影响美国地方政府的 AI 采用。利用逻辑回归和泊松回归模型,我们发现地方政府的 AI 采用与公民对 AI 的态度、公共雇员工会化程度、地方政府的财政能力及基础设施支持相关联。值得注意的是,政治因素(公民态度和公共部门工会化)在解释政府 AI 采用方面与能力因素同等重要,在某些情况下甚至更具影响力。这些发现表明,地方政府间 AI 采用差异不仅源于能力障碍,还源于公共雇员力量及公众关切所导致的政治约束。
查看原文摘要
Artificial Intelligence (AI) has been widely adopted by governments, but whether and to what extent governments adopt AI varies. A key question is whether variation in AI adoption across local governments stems from differences in capacity or political constraints. Understanding this has implications for the kinds of policies officials may want to adopt to ensure that local governments have access to the technologies that they want and need. This paper combines data from the International City/County Management Association (ICMA) Survey, American Trends Panel (ATP), the Current Population Survey (CPS), and other public data sources, to examine how capacity and political constraints influence local government AI adoption in the United States. Using logistic and Poisson regression models, we find that AI adoption at local governments is associated with citizens’ attitudes toward AI, public employee unionization, local governments’ financial capacity, and infrastructure support. Notably, political factors (citizens’ attitudes and public sector unionization) are equally influential as capacity factors in explaining government AI adoption, and in some cases, more powerful. These findings suggest that variation in AI adoption across local governments results not only from capacity barriers but also from political constraints due to the power of public employees and concerns of the public.

作为行政实践的公众参与:来自联邦权利社区的实证证据

Anne R. Williamson

英文原题

Public Participation as Administrative Practice: Evidence from Federal Entitlement Communities

公众参与被广泛认为是民主治理的重要组成部分,然而实证研究往往通过所采用的方法而非参与在行政过程中组织的制度结构来评估参与。基于对 289 个接受联邦整笔拨款的地方辖区的分析,本研究将参与视为一种结构化的行政实践,而非仅仅是参与方法的集合。通过对综合计划的归纳分析,研究构建了四种参与结构的类型学:最低限度合规、结构化咨询、制度化咨询和嵌入式参与。分析识别了参与…

阅读完整摘要 ↗
公众参与被广泛认为是民主治理的重要组成部分,然而实证研究往往通过所采用的方法而非参与在行政过程中组织的制度结构来评估参与。基于对 289 个接受联邦整笔拨款的地方辖区的分析,本研究将参与视为一种结构化的行政实践,而非仅仅是参与方法的集合。通过对综合计划的归纳分析,研究构建了四种参与结构的类型学:最低限度合规、结构化咨询、制度化咨询和嵌入式参与。分析识别了参与在制度上如何组织并融入规划及行政决策过程中的重复模式。尽管辖区经常采用超出法定公开听证会的多种参与方法,但参与最常通过咨询性安排而非嵌入式参与形式来构建。参与结构与人口类别、地区或行政能力的关联仅属中等程度,这表明差异反映了行政在设计及实施参与过程中的选择。通过将关注点从参与方法转向参与结构,本研究为理解地方政府在实践中如何组织公众参与提供了一个框架。更广泛而言,研究结果表明,参与不仅受到政府采用的参与方法的影响,还受到组织参与的制度安排的塑造,突显了参与作为一种由组织设计和裁量权所塑造的行政实践。
查看原文摘要
Public participation is widely recognized as an important component of democratic governance, yet empirical studies often evaluate participation by the methods employed rather than the institutional structures through which participation is organized within administrative processes. Drawing on an analysis of 289 local jurisdictions receiving federal block grants, this study examines participation as structured administrative practice rather than simply a collection of engagement methods. Using inductive analysis of Consolidated Plans, the study develops a typology of four participation structures: Minimal Compliance, Structured Consultation, Institutionalized Consultation, and Embedded Participation. The analysis identifies recurring patterns in how participation is institutionally organized and incorporated into planning and administrative decision-making processes. While jurisdictions frequently employ multiple participation methods beyond required public hearings, participation is most commonly structured through consultative arrangements rather than embedded forms of engagement. Participation structures are only modestly associated with population category, region, or administrative capacity, suggesting that variation reflects administrative choices in the design and implementation of participation processes. By shifting attention from participation methods to participation structures, the study provides a framework for understanding how local governments organize public participation in practice. More broadly, the findings suggest that participation is shaped not only by the engagement methods governments employ but also by the institutional arrangements through which participation is organized, highlighting participation as an administrative practice shaped by organizational design and discretion.

“我们不再被允许做人”:美国警察在 COVID-19 疫情与国内动荡叠加危机中的执法经历

Jess Bonnan-White, Michael Landon-Murray, Anna E. Kosloski, Matthew M. Lunn

英文原题

'We are no longer Allowed to be Human': Officers’ Experiences Policing the Compounding Crises of the COVID-19 Pandemic and Civil Unrest in the United States

地方警察是最为突出的前线公务人员之一,每日与民众、社区及其他机构和利益相关方互动。从最字面的意义上讲,他们是街头层面的官僚。这些互动在 2020 年夏天受到了巨大考验。警察管理——或在某些情况下拒绝管理——全球大流行的执法命令,同时还要在乔治·弗洛伊德谋杀案发生后维持治安。本文探讨了三个地方辖区的警官如何应对这双重且叠加的危机——我们完全可以预期未来还会有更…

阅读完整摘要 ↗
地方警察是最为突出的前线公务人员之一,每日与民众、社区及其他机构和利益相关方互动。从最字面的意义上讲,他们是街头层面的官僚。这些互动在 2020 年夏天受到了巨大考验。警察管理——或在某些情况下拒绝管理——全球大流行的执法命令,同时还要在乔治·弗洛伊德谋杀案发生后维持治安。本文探讨了三个地方辖区的警官如何应对这双重且叠加的危机——我们完全可以预期未来还会有更多此类危机——以及这对警察互动、自由裁量权(包括消极执法)和工作满意度的影响。文章最后讨论了警察领导、地方官员和社区倡导者如何在危机时期更好地支持执法专业人员。
查看原文摘要
Local police officers are among the most prominent frontline public servants, interacting daily with people, communities, and other agencies and stakeholders. They are, in the most literal sense, street-level bureaucrats. These interactions were greatly tested in the summer of 2020. Police managed – or in some cases refused to manage – enforcement orders for a global pandemic while at the same time policing in the aftermath of the murder of George Floyd. This article explores how officers in three local jurisdictions navigated these dual, compounding crises – which we can certainly expect many more of in the future – and the implications for police interactions, discretion (including de-policing) and job satisfaction. The article concludes with a discussion of how police leaders, local officials and community advocates can better support law enforcement professionals during times of crises.

公民政治意识形态是否影响官僚回应性?来自审计实验的证据

Jared Olsen, Mary Feeney

英文原题

Does Citizen Political Ideology Shape Bureaucratic Responsiveness? Evidence From an Audit Experiment

政府工作人员在提供公共服务决策时常常采取捷径。当这些捷径受到刻板印象或偏见的影响时,公民可能会受到不平等的对待。本研究探讨美国住房管理局和公园部门的官僚是否基于公民的政治意识形态进行歧视。通过一项预注册的 2×3 电子邮件审计实验(n=974),我们测试了当公民表达保守观点、自由观点或无政治观点时,回应性是否有所不同。结果显示,街头官僚更倾向于回应表达保守观…

阅读完整摘要 ↗
政府工作人员在提供公共服务决策时常常采取捷径。当这些捷径受到刻板印象或偏见的影响时,公民可能会受到不平等的对待。本研究探讨美国住房管理局和公园部门的官僚是否基于公民的政治意识形态进行歧视。通过一项预注册的 2×3 电子邮件审计实验(n=974),我们测试了当公民表达保守观点、自由观点或无政治观点时,回应性是否有所不同。结果显示,街头官僚更倾向于回应表达保守观点的公民,而非未表明政治观点的公民。对于表达自由观点的公民与未表明政治观点的公民,回应性没有差异。然而,在提供回复的情况下,表达自由观点的公民会收到更有帮助的回复。交互模型表明,对表达自由观点的公民的回应性在公共住房管理局和公园部门之间存在差异。这些发现表明,政治意识形态可能以影响公共服务公平性的方式塑造官僚回应性。
查看原文摘要
Government workers often take shortcuts when making decisions about delivering public services. When these shortcuts are influenced by stereotypes or bias, citizens may receive unequal treatment. This research examines whether bureaucrats in U.S. housing authorities and parks departments discriminate based on citizen political ideology. Using a pre-registered 2 × 3 email audit experiment ( n = 974), we test whether responsiveness varies when citizens signal conservative views, liberal views, or no political views. The results show that street-level bureaucrats are more likely to respond to citizens signaling conservative views than to citizens with no stated political views. Responsiveness does not differ between citizens signaling liberal views and citizens with no stated political views. However, when a reply is provided, citizens signaling liberal views receive more helpful responses. Interaction models suggest that responsiveness to citizens signaling liberal views differs across public housing authorities and parks departments. These findings suggest that political ideology may shape bureaucratic responsiveness in ways that have implications for fairness in public service delivery.
J. of European Public Policy 期刊封面

J. of European Public Policy

九个民主国家中民众对政治家的应得性认知

Bart Maes, Chris Butler, Stefaan Walgrave

英文原题

Deservingness perceptions of politicians in nine democracies

政治家必须在相互竞争的政策主张之间进行裁决,判断哪些应予以倡导,哪些应予以忽视。鉴于时间和资源的限制,政治家在做出此类判断时,很可能依赖于一种“应得性启发式”。然而,关于政治家如何构想不同政策主张的应得性,以及这种构想如何因意识形态而异,我们知之甚少。本文分析了 500 多次对政治家的访谈,探讨政策主张的哪些特征促使他们(不)作出回应。文章考察了政治家在何种…

阅读完整摘要 ↗
政治家必须在相互竞争的政策主张之间进行裁决,判断哪些应予以倡导,哪些应予以忽视。鉴于时间和资源的限制,政治家在做出此类判断时,很可能依赖于一种“应得性启发式”。然而,关于政治家如何构想不同政策主张的应得性,以及这种构想如何因意识形态而异,我们知之甚少。本文分析了 500 多次对政治家的访谈,探讨政策主张的哪些特征促使他们(不)作出回应。文章考察了政治家在何种情况下自发地将应得性作为指导原则,以及他们如何判定一项主张的应得性。我们发现,应得性是政治家广泛应用于广泛政策领域的一个普遍标准。此外,我们发现在政治家应用应得性评估时存在意识形态差异:那些偏离意识形态中心较远的人更倾向于对特定社会群体是否(不)应得作出明确判断。总体而言,我们揭示了许多政治家通过关于社会群体的道德和政治判断来过滤政策主张,强调了对政策主张的回应性在这些不同群体之间既非平等也非一致。
查看原文摘要
Politicians have to adjudicate between competing policy claims, making judgments as to which to advocate for and which to disregard. Given time and resource constraints, politicians are likely to rely on a deservingness heuristic when making such judgements. However, little is known about how politicians conceive of the deservingness of different policy claims and how this varies by ideology. This paper analyses over 500 interviews with politicians about which characteristics of policy claims prompt them (not) to respond. It explores the circumstances under which politicians spontaneously invoke deservingness as a guiding principle, and how they determine a claim’s deservingness. We find that deservingness is a prevalent criterion that politicians apply to a wide range of policy domains. Further, we find ideological differences in how politicians apply deservingness evaluations: those further from the ideological centre are more likely to make pronounced judgments about whether specific social groups are (un-)deserving. Overall, we reveal that many politicians filter policy claims through moral and political judgments about social groups, highlighting that responsiveness to policy claims is neither equal nor consistent across these different groups.

民族主义政党与跨国界分歧

Christina Isabel Zuber, Paul Bederke, Edina Szöcsik

英文原题

Nationalist parties and the transnational cleavage

欧洲政党政治正围绕一个跨国竞争维度进行重新整合,这一维度将世界主义政党——支持移民、欧洲一体化及气候政策——与反对这些议题的激进右翼政党对立起来。激进右翼政党有时被等同于民族主义政党。然而,在欧洲的多民族民主国家中,民族主义具有高度多样性。多民族民主国家的特点是存在显著的“中心-边缘”冲突,其中多数民族主义政党与代表边缘民族的少数民族主义者相对立。虽然多数民…

阅读完整摘要 ↗
欧洲政党政治正围绕一个跨国竞争维度进行重新整合,这一维度将世界主义政党——支持移民、欧洲一体化及气候政策——与反对这些议题的激进右翼政党对立起来。激进右翼政党有时被等同于民族主义政党。然而,在欧洲的多民族民主国家中,民族主义具有高度多样性。多民族民主国家的特点是存在显著的“中心-边缘”冲突,其中多数民族主义政党与代表边缘民族的少数民族主义者相对立。虽然多数民族主义者预计会趋同于跨国分裂中的特殊主义一极,但少数民族主义者则有战略理由采取更为世界主义的立场:他们需要国际盟友,并寻求与主要国内对手——多数民族主义者——区分开来。本分析基于 2023 年版的一项专家调查,该调查旨在将民族主义意识形态与文化价值观分开测量,并区分多数民族主义与少数民族主义。对 21 个国家中 89 个民族主义政党的分析证实,尽管多数民族主义者将自己定位在跨国分裂的特殊主义一极,但少数民族主义者比多数民族主义者更亲欧洲、更支持气候政策——但在移民问题上并非如此。有趣的是,世界主义也出现在较小边缘国家(如波斯尼亚和黑塞哥维那或科索沃)的多数民族主义者中。
查看原文摘要
European party politics has been realigning around a transnational dimension of competition that pits cosmopolitan parties — favouring immigration, European integration, and climate policy — against radical right parties that oppose these. Radical right parties are sometimes equated with nationalist parties. However, nationalism is highly diverse in Europe’s multinational democracies. Multinational democracies are characterised by a salient centre-periphery conflict, in which majority nationalist parties confront minority nationalists representing peripheral nations. While majority nationalists can be expected to converge on the particularist pole of the transnational cleavage, minority nationalists have strategic reasons to adopt more cosmopolitan stances: they need international allies and seek to differentiate themselves from majority nationalists, their main domestic opponents. The analysis draws on the 2023 edition of an expert survey designed to measure nationalist ideology separately from cultural values, and to differentiate majority from minority nationalism. Analysing 89 nationalist parties in 21 countries confirms that while majority nationalists position themselves on the particularist pole of the transnational cleavage, minority nationalists are more pro-European and more in favour of climate policy — but not more in favour of immigration — than majority nationalists. Interestingly, cosmopolitanism appears also among majority nationalists in smaller peripheral countries, like Bosnia and Herzegovina or Kosovo.
Public Administration 期刊封面

Public Administration

150 年历史的混合组织:瑞典市属公司的历史视角

Anna Thomasson, Olof Hallonsten

英文原题

The 150‐Year‐Old Hybrid Organization: A Historical View on Municipally Owned Corporations ( MOC ) in Sweden

本文对瑞典市属企业(MOCs)150 年的发展进行了纵向分析,追溯了其 19 世纪中叶的兴起、福利国家扩张时期的扩展,以及市场化公共部门改革时代的转型。尽管市属企业通常与新公共管理(NPM)及当代混合治理形式相关联,但这一视角忽视了其更为悠久的历史轨迹。基于瑞典三次重大政府调查(1924 年、1965 年和 1982 年),并辅以二手历史资料,我们考察了市属…

阅读完整摘要 ↗
本文对瑞典市属企业(MOCs)150 年的发展进行了纵向分析,追溯了其 19 世纪中叶的兴起、福利国家扩张时期的扩展,以及市场化公共部门改革时代的转型。尽管市属企业通常与新公共管理(NPM)及当代混合治理形式相关联,但这一视角忽视了其更为悠久的历史轨迹。基于瑞典三次重大政府调查(1924 年、1965 年和 1982 年),并辅以二手历史资料,我们考察了市属企业在政治、经济和行政环境变迁中的演变过程。本文将市属企业概念化为宪法性混合体,即通过设计将公共权力与企业治理要素相结合的组织,并运用制度理论与历史制度主义的洞见分析其长期发展。研究发现揭示了三个历史阶段,其特征表现为功能、治理逻辑和制度期望的变化。在这些时期,市属企业不断被重新诠释并适应新环境,同时保持了其基本的组织形式。本研究通过证明混合性不应仅被理解为公共部门改革的当代结果,而应被视为一种历史演进的制度条件,为混合性文献做出了贡献。我们认为,市属企业的持续存在反映了混合组织形式的适应能力,其灵活性使其能够满足对效率、合法性、问责制和公共价值不断变化的需求。通过将混合性历史化,本文为制度韧性及公共治理的长期演变提供了新的视角。
查看原文摘要
This article presents a 150‐year longitudinal analysis of the development of municipally owned corporations (MOCs) in Sweden, tracing their emergence in the mid‐nineteenth century, their expansion during the growth of the welfare state, and their transformation in the era of market‐oriented public sector reform. While MOCs are commonly discussed in relation to New Public Management (NPM) and contemporary forms of hybrid governance, this perspective overlooks their much longer historical trajectory. Drawing on three major Swedish government inquiries (1924, 1965, and 1982), complemented by secondary historical sources, we examine how MOCs have evolved across changing political, economic, and administrative contexts. The article conceptualizes MOCs as constitutional hybrids, organizations that combine elements of public authority and corporate governance by design, and employs insights from institutional theory and historical institutionalism to analyze their long‐term development. The findings identify three historical phases characterized by changing functions, governance rationales, and institutional expectations. Across these periods, MOCs were repeatedly reinterpreted and adapted to new circumstances while maintaining their basic organizational form. The study contributes to the literature on hybridity by demonstrating that hybridity should be understood not merely as a contemporary consequence of public sector reform, but as a historically evolving institutional condition. We argue that the enduring presence of MOCs reflects the adaptive capacity of hybrid organizational forms, whose flexibility allows them to accommodate shifting demands for efficiency, legitimacy, accountability, and public value. By historicizing hybridity, the article offers a new perspective on institutional resilience, and the long‐term evolution of public governance.

《“你的金钱、你的生命,还是你的自由?公共卫生危机期间权衡取舍的离散选择实验”的重复研究》

Binzizi Dong, Chung‐An Chen, Soojin Kim, Chih‐Wei Hsieh

英文原题

A Replication of “Your Money, Your Life, or Your Freedom? A Discrete Choice Experiment on Trade‐Offs During a Public Health Crisis”

一项先前在意大利进行的实验考察了在政府强制封锁期间,个体如何在金钱、生命与自由之间进行权衡取舍。本研究在三个儒家社会——上海(中国)、新加坡和台北(台湾)——复制了该实验。研究结果显示,在总体样本中,“金钱 > 生命 > 自由”的偏好模式与原始研究报告的结果一致。然而,当分别分析时,台北居民对收入和自由的偏好强于新加坡和上海居民。相反,新加坡人对生命损失表现…

阅读完整摘要 ↗
一项先前在意大利进行的实验考察了在政府强制封锁期间,个体如何在金钱、生命与自由之间进行权衡取舍。本研究在三个儒家社会——上海(中国)、新加坡和台北(台湾)——复制了该实验。研究结果显示,在总体样本中,“金钱 > 生命 > 自由”的偏好模式与原始研究报告的结果一致。然而,当分别分析时,台北居民对收入和自由的偏好强于新加坡和上海居民。相反,新加坡人对生命损失表现出更高的关注。除了复制先前的研究发现外,本研究还通过强调公共管理者在制定危机管理实践时考虑情境细微差别的重要性,为比较公共行政领域做出了贡献。
查看原文摘要
A prior experiment conducted in Italy examined how individuals navigate trade‐offs among money, life, and freedom during government‐mandated lockdowns. This study replicates that experiment across three Confucian societies: Shanghai (China), Singapore, and Taipei (Taiwan). The findings indicate that, in the aggregate sample, the preference pattern of “money > life > freedom” mirrors that reported in the original study. However, when analyzed separately, residents of Taipei show stronger preferences for income and freedom than their counterparts in Singapore and Shanghai. Conversely, Singaporeans demonstrate heightened concern regarding the loss of life. In addition to replicating previous findings, this study contributes to the field of comparative public administration by highlighting the importance of considering contextual nuances in the formulation of crisis‐management practices by public managers.

《复制研究:“内容并非唯一关键——规则传达方式对行政负担的影响”》

Qi Bian, Luning Xin, Ben Ma

英文原题

A Replication of “It is Not Merely About the Content: How Rules Are Communicated Matters to Administrative Burden”

本研究在复制先前研究以考察规则沟通形式如何塑造行政负担的基础上,进一步拓展了研究范围,探讨人工智能(AI)服务如何调节这一关系。AI 服务被理解为执行两种不同功能:标签功能,即聊天机器人直接根据用户查询从数据库中输出政策规则,无需进一步处理;以及优化功能,即聊天机器人收集、分析并提炼规则信息,向用户呈现简化、优先排序的关键要点。在研究 1 中,原始研究在中国…

阅读完整摘要 ↗
本研究在复制先前研究以考察规则沟通形式如何塑造行政负担的基础上,进一步拓展了研究范围,探讨人工智能(AI)服务如何调节这一关系。AI 服务被理解为执行两种不同功能:标签功能,即聊天机器人直接根据用户查询从数据库中输出政策规则,无需进一步处理;以及优化功能,即聊天机器人收集、分析并提炼规则信息,向用户呈现简化、优先排序的关键要点。在研究 1 中,原始研究在中国自然灾害救助申请情境下进行了复制。研究结果表明,官僚式语言提高了学习成本和合规成本,并增加了压力和自主权丧失感,而复杂的信息结构也增加了学习成本、合规成本和自主权丧失感。这些结果证实,规则沟通在政策、国家和语言层面均塑造了行政负担。然而,与原始研究相比,出现了差异,原始研究中官僚式语言引发了污名化,而信息复杂性对合规成本或自主权丧失无影响,这可能归因于情境因素,如中文表意文字的复杂性。在此基础上,研究 2 的扩展实验表明,AI 服务降低了行政负担。值得注意的是,与预期相反,标签功能减少了学习成本、合规成本和心理成本,而优化功能在所有维度上实现了更大的降低。总体而言,这些发现为利用 AI 改善规则沟通并减轻行政负担提供了实证支持。
查看原文摘要
This study replicates prior research to examine how rule communication forms shape administrative burden, while also extending their research by investigating how artificial intelligence (AI) services moderate this relationship. AI services are understood to perform two distinct functions: the labeling function, where chatbots output policy rules directly from databases in response to user queries without further processing, and the optimization function, where chatbots collect, analyze, and distill rule information to present users with simplified, prioritized key points. In Study 1, the original research is replicated in the context of natural disaster relief applications in China. The findings demonstrate that bureaucratic language raises learning and compliance costs, stress, and autonomy loss, while complex information structures also increase learning costs, compliance costs, and autonomy loss. These results confirm that rule communication shapes administrative burden across policies, countries, and languages. However, differences emerge compared to the original study, in which bureaucratic language induced stigma and information complexity had no effect on compliance or autonomy loss, potentially due to contextual factors such as the complexity of Chinese logographic writing. Building on this, the extension experiment in Study 2 demonstrates that AI services reduce administrative burden. Notably, and contrary to expectations, the labeling function reduces learning, compliance, and psychological costs, while the optimization function achieves even greater reductions across all dimensions. Collectively, these findings provide empirical evidence supporting the use of AI to improve rule communication and ease administrative burden.

监管俘获、公众信任与亲环境行为

Songsong Chen, Jianhua Xu

英文原题

Regulatory Capture, Public Trust and Pro‐Environmental Behaviors

监管俘获,即特殊利益集团使监管偏离公共利益的现象,虽被广泛讨论,但其更广泛的公共后果仍未得到充分探索。我们利用中国在线调查数据,探讨了感知到的监管俘获、公众信任与亲环境行为之间的关系。研究发现,感知到的物质俘获与信息俘获(后者通过单一基于情景的代理指标衡量)与公众对地方政府(b = −0.154,−0.105)和中央政府(b = −0.087,−0.064)…

阅读完整摘要 ↗
监管俘获,即特殊利益集团使监管偏离公共利益的现象,虽被广泛讨论,但其更广泛的公共后果仍未得到充分探索。我们利用中国在线调查数据,探讨了感知到的监管俘获、公众信任与亲环境行为之间的关系。研究发现,感知到的物质俘获与信息俘获(后者通过单一基于情景的代理指标衡量)与公众对地方政府(b = −0.154,−0.105)和中央政府(b = −0.087,−0.064)的信任均呈显著负相关。在公共领域中,与非行动主义亲环境行为的直接关联始终为负,并得到跨规格自助法置信区间的支持(物质:β = −0.066 至−0.082;信息:β = −0.036 至−0.047),而若干对应的私人领域关联则不显著。间接关联仅在特定模型中成立。这些发现凸显了监管俘获的公共影响,区分了物质俘获与信息俘获,并拓展了对公众信任与亲环境行为的理解。
查看原文摘要
Regulatory capture, where special interests steer regulation away from public interest, is widely discussed, but its broader public consequences remain underexplored. We explore the relationship between perceived regulatory capture, public trust and pro‐environmental behaviors using online survey data in China. Findings show that perceived material and information capture (the latter measured with a single scenario‐based proxy) have significant negative associations with public trust in local ( b = −0.154, −0.105) and central government ( b = −0.087, −0.064). Direct associations with non‐activist pro‐environmental behaviors in the public sphere are consistently negative and supported by bootstrapped confidence intervals across specifications (material: β = −0.066 to −0.082; information: β = −0.036 to −0.047), whereas several corresponding private sphere associations are not. Indirect associations are supported only in selected models. These findings highlight the public implications of regulatory capture, distinguishing material and information capture, and extend understanding of public trust and pro‐environmental behaviors.

合适的钥匙开合适的锁:政府回应方式与需求类型如何影响公民满意度

Na Tang, Wenjia Huang, Nana Huang, Mengyao Zhang

英文原题

The Right Key for the Right Lock: How Government Response Methods and Demand Types Affect Citizen Satisfaction

面对公民多样化且复杂的需求,政府一直在寻求提升其回应能力的方法。比喻而言,公民的需求可视为锁,而政府需要钥匙来开启它们。人工智能(AI)作为一种创新性的新钥匙,为开启通往高公民满意度之门提供了全新范式。本研究基于政府回应理论,采用 2×3 被试间调查实验,探讨政府回应方式(传统回应、AI 赋能回应)与公民需求类型(咨询、投诉/求助、建议)对公民满意度的影响。…

阅读完整摘要 ↗
面对公民多样化且复杂的需求,政府一直在寻求提升其回应能力的方法。比喻而言,公民的需求可视为锁,而政府需要钥匙来开启它们。人工智能(AI)作为一种创新性的新钥匙,为开启通往高公民满意度之门提供了全新范式。本研究基于政府回应理论,采用 2×3 被试间调查实验,探讨政府回应方式(传统回应、AI 赋能回应)与公民需求类型(咨询、投诉/求助、建议)对公民满意度的影响。研究发现,相较于传统方式,AI 赋能的政府回应显著提升了公民满意度。在需求类型中,咨询类需求带来的满意度最高,而建议类需求导致的满意度最低。此外,回应方式与需求类型之间的交互效应显著影响满意度水平。感知公平在政府回应与公民满意度之间起中介作用,而公民参与经历则具有调节效应。本研究从政府回应的视角为提升公民满意度提供了新见解,揭示了 AI 赋能政府回应的内容依赖性特征,有助于政府制定独特的 AI 回应策略,并增强与公民的数字互动。
查看原文摘要
Faced with diverse and complex demands from citizens, the government has consistently sought ways to enhance its ability to respond. Metaphorically, citizens' needs can be viewed as locks, and the government requires keys to unlock them. Artificial intelligence (AI) is an innovative new key offering a fresh paradigm for unlocking the door to high citizen satisfaction. Drawing on government responsiveness theory, this study applies a 2 × 3 between‐subjects survey experiment to explore the impact of government response methods (traditional responses, AI‐enabled responses) and citizen demand types (consultation, complaint/help‐seeking, suggestions) on citizen satisfaction. Findings show that AI‐enabled government responses significantly increase citizen satisfaction compared to traditional approaches. Among demand types, consultation yields the highest satisfaction, while suggestion results in the lowest. Further, the satisfaction level is significantly influenced by the interaction effect between response method and demand type. Perceived fairness mediates the relationship between government responses and citizen satisfaction, with citizen participation experience having a moderating effect. This study offers new insights into increasing citizen satisfaction from the perspective of government responses. It reveals the content‐dependent nature of AI‐enabled government responses, helping the government create unique AI response strategies and enhance digital interaction with citizens.
Public Performance & Mgmt Review 期刊封面

Public Performance & Mgmt Review

评估公民报告平台的成熟度:解析维度、差异与决定因素

Iris Saliterer, Kathrin Leppert, Lisa Hohensinn

英文原题

Assessing the Maturity of Citizen Reporting Platforms: Unpacking Dimensions, Disparities, and Determinants

公民举报平台(CRPs)被广泛采用,并常被视为促进公民参与服务评估的工具。然而,关于这些平台在多大程度上超越单向问题举报、支持更具实质性的公民参与形式,目前知之甚少。本文构建了一个多维框架,并将其应用于德国中等规模城市的 194 个公民举报平台,这一群体在以往研究中被忽视。借鉴 DeLone 和 McLean 信息系统成功模型及共同生产研究,我们将成熟度概念…

阅读完整摘要 ↗
公民举报平台(CRPs)被广泛采用,并常被视为促进公民参与服务评估的工具。然而,关于这些平台在多大程度上超越单向问题举报、支持更具实质性的公民参与形式,目前知之甚少。本文构建了一个多维框架,并将其应用于德国中等规模城市的 194 个公民举报平台,这一群体在以往研究中被忽视。借鉴 DeLone 和 McLean 信息系统成功模型及共同生产研究,我们将成熟度概念化为平台功能在四个维度上的广度与组合:沟通、可用性、响应性和问责性。我们发现整体成熟度存在显著差异。可用性是最发达的维度,而响应性和问责性明显较少见,从而在可见、可追溯和可评估的公民参与条件方面产生了问责缺口。响应性和问责性往往在可用性基础设施较为完善的平台上共同出现——这是一种累积模式。回归分析识别出外部实施是成熟度最强且最一致的关联因素,而市政对平台相关询问的响应性则是一个较为有限但显著的因素。本研究提供了一个可转移的评估框架,并揭示了基本举报与更全面共同评估的平台侧设计条件之间的差距。
查看原文摘要
Citizen reporting platforms (CRPs) are widely adopted and frequently framed as tools for citizen involvement in service assessment. Yet little is known about the extent to which these platforms move beyond one-way issue reporting to support more substantive forms of citizen involvement. This article develops a multidimensional framework and applies it to 194 CRPs across German mid-sized municipalities, a group overlooked in prior research. Drawing on the DeLone and McLean information systems success model and co-production research, we conceptualize maturity as the breadth and combination of platform features across four dimensions: communication, usability, responsiveness, and accountability. We find substantial variation in overall maturity. Usability is the most developed dimension, whereas responsiveness and accountability are markedly less common, producing an accountability gap in the conditions for visible, traceable, and evaluable forms of citizen involvement. Responsiveness and accountability tend to co-occur on platforms with more developed usability infrastructures—a cumulative pattern. Regression analyses identify external implementation as the strongest and most consistent correlate of maturity, while municipal responsiveness to a platform-related inquiry is a more limited but significant factor. The study provides a transferable assessment framework and highlights the gap between basic reporting and the platform-side design conditions for fuller co-assessment.

当科技遇见文化:数字共同生产与公共价值创造

Huan-Sheng Lin

英文原题

When Technology Meets Culture: Digital Co-Production and Public Value Creation

数字技术被广泛认为能够促进公民参与的民主化,然而其对共同生产的实际影响在理论上仍缺乏明确界定。本研究通过对台湾“街道医生改善计划”——一项国家级数字共同生产倡议(旨在提升行人安全)——的质性分析,探讨数字技术如何塑造共同生产。研究发现挑战了数字治理文献中的既有假设,并引出三项理论修正。首先,数字平台展现出双重属性——既通过降低参与门槛赋权公民,又通过议程设置…

阅读完整摘要 ↗
数字技术被广泛认为能够促进公民参与的民主化,然而其对共同生产的实际影响在理论上仍缺乏明确界定。本研究通过对台湾“街道医生改善计划”——一项国家级数字共同生产倡议(旨在提升行人安全)——的质性分析,探讨数字技术如何塑造共同生产。研究发现挑战了数字治理文献中的既有假设,并引出三项理论修正。首先,数字平台展现出双重属性——既通过降低参与门槛赋权公民,又通过议程设置与数据所有权强化政府控制。其次,有效的数字共同生产依赖于动态的制度性工作;台湾的全额政府资助机制与公民投票制度展示了政策行动者如何在既有制度约束之外进行创新。第三,公共价值的创造被证明具有文化情境性而非普遍性;参与表现为有组织的平台挪用形式,邻里代表及其他组织化行动者以挑战以个体为中心的数字共同生产叙事的方式动员并争夺这一过程。通过整合共同生产理论、公共服务生态系统视角及制度性工作概念,本研究推动数字治理学术研究超越单一层次分析,迈向多行动者、多层次框架。研究结果为设计具有文化敏感性的数字治理提供了实践指导,并为关于数字参与是否创造真正公共价值或仅为象征性包容的争论提供了启示。
查看原文摘要
Digital technologies are widely assumed to democratize citizen participation, yet their actual effects on co-production remain theoretically underspecified. This study examines how digital technologies shape co-production through a qualitative analysis of Taiwan’s Street Doctor Improvement Program—a national-level digital co-production initiative for pedestrian safety. The findings challenge prevailing assumptions in the digital governance literature and lead to three theoretical modifications. First, digital platforms exhibit a dual nature—empowering citizens through lowered participation barriers while enabling governmental control through agenda-setting and data ownership. Second, effective digital co-production depends on dynamic institutional work; Taiwan’s full government funding mechanism and citizen voting system demonstrate how policy actors innovate beyond existing institutional constraints. Third, public value creation proves culturally contextualized rather than universal; participation took the form of organized platform appropriation, as neighborhood representatives and other organized actors mobilized and contested it in ways that challenge individual-centered accounts of digital co-production. By integrating co-production theory, public service ecosystem perspectives, and institutional work concepts, this study advances digital governance scholarship beyond single-level analyses toward a multi-actor, multi-level framework. The findings offer practical guidance for designing culturally sensitive digital governance and inform the debate over whether digital participation creates genuine public value or merely symbolic inclusion.

评估乡村发展项目中村民对性别刻板印象领导者的偏好:以斯里兰卡农村为例

Niranjala Hulugalla, Mai Seki, Kyohei Yamada, Makoto Kakinaka

英文原题

Assessing Villagers’ Preferences of Gender-Stereotypic Leaders in Village Development Programs: The Case of Rural Sri Lanka

本研究通过区分基于类别的评价(基于候选人性别的偏好)与基于属性的评价(基于与性别相关的领导特质的偏好),探讨村民在社区项目中如何评估领导候选人。尽管近期研究表明,通常与女性气质相关的领导品质日益受到积极评价,但在许多农村社区,女性在领导角色中的代表性仍然不足。这一差异引发了一个问题:在领导者选拔中,性别本身还是与性别相关的领导特质发挥更重要的作用。为探究此问…

阅读完整摘要 ↗
本研究通过区分基于类别的评价(基于候选人性别的偏好)与基于属性的评价(基于与性别相关的领导特质的偏好),探讨村民在社区项目中如何评估领导候选人。尽管近期研究表明,通常与女性气质相关的领导品质日益受到积极评价,但在许多农村社区,女性在领导角色中的代表性仍然不足。这一差异引发了一个问题:在领导者选拔中,性别本身还是与性别相关的领导特质发挥更重要的作用。为探究此问题,我们在斯里兰卡农村对 1,147 名村民进行了一项基于选择的联合实验,受访者评估了乡村发展项目主席职位的假设候选人。候选人档案在五个维度上随机变化:性别、领导特质(能动性或社群性)、领导风格(专制或民主)、政策优先领域(财政、基础设施、教育或医疗)以及性别意识形态(保守或自由)。结果显示村民领导评价中存在一个重要模式。尽管受访者偏好具有民主领导风格和自由性别意识形态的候选人,但他们始终更倾向于男性候选人而非女性候选人。相比之下,领导特质和政策优先领域对候选人选择无显著影响。这些发现表明,即使与女性气质相关的领导属性受到重视,基于类别的性别偏见依然存在。
查看原文摘要
This study examines how villagers evaluate leadership candidates in community-based programs by distinguishing between category-based evaluation (preferences based on a candidate’s gender) and attribute-based evaluation (preferences based on gender-associated leadership characteristics). Although recent studies suggest that leadership qualities commonly associated with femininity are increasingly viewed positively, women remain underrepresented in leadership roles in many rural communities. This discrepancy raises the question of whether gender itself or gender-associated leadership characteristics play a stronger role in leader selection. To investigate this issue, we conducted a choice-based conjoint experiment with 1,147 villagers in rural Sri Lanka, in which respondents evaluated hypothetical candidates for the chairperson position of Village Development Programs. Candidate profiles randomly varied across five dimensions: gender, leadership trait (agentic or communal), leadership style (autocratic or democratic), policy priority area (finance, infrastructure, education, or healthcare), and gender ideology (conservative or liberal). The results reveal an important pattern in villagers’ leadership evaluations. Although respondents prefer candidates with democratic leadership styles and liberal gender ideologies, they consistently favor male candidates over female candidates. In contrast, leadership traits and policy priorities do not significantly influence candidate choice. These findings indicate that category-based gender bias persists even when leadership attributes associated with femininity are valued.

可持续性反馈控制:受限地方政府中的综合规划、能力与绩效管理

Aaron Deslatte, Yunchen Zhu

英文原题

Feedback Control for Sustainability: Integrated Planning, Capabilities and Performance Management in Constrained Local Governments

全球各地的地方政府正日益遭受洪水、干旱和野火等极端气候事件的影响。这促使公共管理者更加积极地评估和应对支撑公共物品或服务的可持续性基础设施。本研究探讨了地方政府如何整合可持续性相关的规划、能力和绩效信息使用,以此作为监管反馈控制的手段。我们的主要研究目标是更深入地理解在人类世背景下,资源受限的小型政府如何以及为何增强其处理的反馈类型。基于美国印第安纳州各市镇…

阅读完整摘要 ↗
全球各地的地方政府正日益遭受洪水、干旱和野火等极端气候事件的影响。这促使公共管理者更加积极地评估和应对支撑公共物品或服务的可持续性基础设施。本研究探讨了地方政府如何整合可持续性相关的规划、能力和绩效信息使用,以此作为监管反馈控制的手段。我们的主要研究目标是更深入地理解在人类世背景下,资源受限的小型政府如何以及为何增强其处理的反馈类型。基于美国印第安纳州各市镇的文本、环境及调查数据独特数据集,我们发现,在综合土地利用和资本规划中更广泛的探索性信息收集,以及在可持续性努力上更大的财政投资,与可持续性相关绩效信息的使用呈正相关。然而,我们未发现以可持续性为重点的经济发展规划、专门的行政能力与绩效使用之间存在关联,这反映出在适应模糊威胁时,调整现有流程和能力所面临的资源限制和挑战。
查看原文摘要
Local governments worldwide are increasingly experiencing the impacts of extreme climate events such as flooding, drought and wildfires. This has created a growing impetus on the part of public administrators to better assess and address the sustainability of the infrastructures which support public goods or services. This study investigates efforts to integrate local government sustainability-related planning, capabilities and performance information use as a means of regulatory feedback control. Our primary research objective is to better understand how and why constrained, smaller governments enhance the types of feedback they process in the Anthropocene. Drawing from a unique dataset of text, environmental and survey data from municipalities in the U.S. state of Indiana, we find greater exploratory information-gathering in comprehensive land-use and capital planning, and greater financial investment in sustainability efforts, are positively associated with sustainability-related performance information use. We find no linkage between sustainability-focused economic development planning, dedicated administrative capacity and performance use, indicative of the resource-constraints and challenges in adapting existing processes and capacities for ambiguous threats.
Administration & Society 期刊封面

Administration & Society

通过绿色小额金融策略促进农村地区女性赋权:来自东松巴塔帕瓦拉巴迪社区的证据

Min-Sun Kim

英文原题

Promoting the Empowerment of Women in Rural Settings Through Green Microfinance Strategies: Evidence From the Tapa Walla Badi Community in East Sumba

本研究探讨了绿色小额信贷在赋能印度尼西亚东松巴农村女性中的作用,特别聚焦于塔帕瓦拉巴迪小组。采用 PLS-SEM 方法,分析了金融知识、态度和行为对绿色微型企业成功及经济独立性的影响。研究发现,金融知识与增长之间的关联较为微弱,但其与审慎金融行为之间的关系在统计上显著。相反,金融态度未显示出明显影响。此外,绿色小额信贷政策在企业成功与独立性之间的关系中并未起…

阅读完整摘要 ↗
本研究探讨了绿色小额信贷在赋能印度尼西亚东松巴农村女性中的作用,特别聚焦于塔帕瓦拉巴迪小组。采用 PLS-SEM 方法,分析了金融知识、态度和行为对绿色微型企业成功及经济独立性的影响。研究发现,金融知识与增长之间的关联较为微弱,但其与审慎金融行为之间的关系在统计上显著。相反,金融态度未显示出明显影响。此外,绿色小额信贷政策在企业成功与独立性之间的关系中并未起到显著的调节作用。这些结果强调了针对性金融教育的必要性,以增强女性赋权并支持农村社区内可持续绿色企业的发展。
查看原文摘要
This study explores green microfinance’s role in empowering rural women in East Sumba, Indonesia, specifically the Tapa Walla Badi group. Using PLS-SEM, it analyzes how financial knowledge, attitudes, and behaviors impact green micro-enterprise success and economic independence. Findings reveal that financial knowledge shows a marginal association with growth, while its relationship with prudent financial behaviors is statistically significant. Conversely, financial attitudes have no discernible impact. Additionally, green microfinance policy does not significantly moderate the relationship between enterprise success and independence. These results emphasize the necessity of targeted financial education to bolster women’s empowerment and support sustainable green business development within rural communities.

人工智能辅助治理模式下算法透明度与董事会问责机制的优化路径研究

Ling Jin

英文原题

Research on the Optimisation Path of Algorithm Transparency and Board Accountability Mechanisms in an Artificial Intelligence-Assisted Governance Model

算法触发的治理在人工智能融合机构中仍发展不足,导致决策延迟和未解决异常。本研究旨在评估嵌入机构董事会工作流程中的人工智能升级模型在精确性、延迟和解决结果方面的表现。研究从 30 名参与者处收集了 300 个人工智能生成的升级案例,按法律、行政和技术角色分层。使用角色校准界面和分级触发阈值对标注案例进行评估。模型采用基于规则的路径选择进行训练和测试,并辅以自助…

阅读完整摘要 ↗
算法触发的治理在人工智能融合机构中仍发展不足,导致决策延迟和未解决异常。本研究旨在评估嵌入机构董事会工作流程中的人工智能升级模型在精确性、延迟和解决结果方面的表现。研究从 30 名参与者处收集了 300 个人工智能生成的升级案例,按法律、行政和技术角色分层。使用角色校准界面和分级触发阈值对标注案例进行评估。模型采用基于规则的路径选择进行训练和测试,并辅以自助法验证。通过方差分析、Kruskal–Wallis 检验和效应量指标进行了干预前后比较分析和亚组比较。所有分析均在 Python 中完成。解释准确率介于 74.9% 至 91.4% 之间,其中人工智能分析师表现最佳。路径选择精确性峰值达到 88.2%,董事会行动成功率为 82.5%,工具提示交互平均点击次数为 10.5 次。界面优化使任务准确率提高了 7.0%,延迟减少了 560 毫秒,路径选择成功率提高了 8.2%。各领域的升级延迟减少了 630 至 650 毫秒。触发特异性灵敏度在重新分类方面最高(92.1%),最终解决时间平均为 4,510 毫秒。异常值修正后收益较小(<1.2%),而错误路径选择占未解决率最高(40.0%)。结构化升级协议显著增强了人工智能治理一致性,并减少了关键响应延迟。
查看原文摘要
Algorithmically-triggered governance remains underdeveloped in AI-integrated institutions, leading to decision delays and unresolved anomalies. This study aimed to evaluate precision, latency, and resolution outcomes of AI-escalation models embedded in institutional board workflows. The study collected 300 AI-generated escalation cases from 30 participants, stratified by legal, administrative, and technical roles. Annotated cases were evaluated using role-calibrated interfaces and tiered trigger thresholds. Models were trained and tested using rule-based routing with bootstrap validation. Comparative analyses (pre- and post-intervention) and subgroup comparisons were performed using ANOVA, the Kruskal–Wallis test, and effect size metrics. All analyses were conducted in Python. Interpretation accuracy ranged from 74.9% to 91.4%, with AI analysts achieving the highest performance. Routing precision peaked at 88.2%, board action success at 82.5%, and tooltip interaction averaged 10.5 clicks. Interface refinement improved task accuracy by 7.0%, decreased latency by 560 ms, and increased routing success by 8.2%. Escalation latency reduced by 630 to 650 ms across domains. Trigger-specific sensitivity was highest for reclassification (92.1%), with final resolution times averaging 4,510 ms. Post-outlier corrections yielded minor gains (<1.2%), and misroutes accounted for the highest unresolved rates (40.0%). Structured escalation protocols notably enhanced AI-governance alignment and reduce critical response delays.

在官僚化与市场化时代做治疗师:心理学家对道德压力的回应

Linda Krikken Mulders, Evelien Tonkens, Margo Trappenburg

英文原题

Being a Therapist in an Age of Bureaucracy and Marketization: Psychologists’ Responses to Moral Stress

自官僚制与新公共管理政策实施以来,心理健康护理专业人员面临的工作压力和道德压力日益增加。我们采访了荷兰心理学家,运用赫希曼的“退出、呼声与忠诚”框架,探究其应对策略。鉴于其工作的孤立性,许多心理学家发展出个体化应对方式,创造性地交替使用不同策略以缓解压力。这无意中导致问题未能充分被问题化以引发变革,而专业人员自身却日益变得愤世嫉俗。我们建议进行系统改革,以保…

阅读完整摘要 ↗
自官僚制与新公共管理政策实施以来,心理健康护理专业人员面临的工作压力和道德压力日益增加。我们采访了荷兰心理学家,运用赫希曼的“退出、呼声与忠诚”框架,探究其应对策略。鉴于其工作的孤立性,许多心理学家发展出个体化应对方式,创造性地交替使用不同策略以缓解压力。这无意中导致问题未能充分被问题化以引发变革,而专业人员自身却日益变得愤世嫉俗。我们建议进行系统改革,以保护专业人员的道德投入,并支持集体策略,从而有效解决问题并实现必要的改进。
查看原文摘要
Mental health care professionals have faced increased work pressure and moral stress since the implementation of bureaucratic and NPM policies. We interviewed Dutch psychologists to investigate how they cope, using Hirschman’s Exit , Voice , and Loyalty framework. Reflecting the solitary nature of their work, many psychologists developed individual approaches, creatively alternating between strategies to relieve pressure. Inadvertently, this contributes to a situation where issues are insufficiently problematized to induce change, while professionals themselves grow more cynical. We recommend system changes to protect professionals’ moral engagement and support collective strategies to address problems effectively and achieve necessary improvements.

治理、基础设施与多维贫困政策:全球研究的比较洞见

Septiawan Ardiputra, Laila Qadrini, Mu’man Nuryana, Burhanuddin, Thamrin Pawalluri et al.

英文原题

Governance, Infrastructure, and Multidimensional Poverty Policies: Comparative Insights From Global Studies

贫困仍然是一个由社会不平等、基本服务获取受限以及环境风险驱动的持续性全球挑战。尽管在减少极端贫困方面取得了进展,但实现包容性和可持续的减贫仍需有效的治理、基础设施建设和多维度的政策干预。本研究采用混合方法综述设计,将文献计量分析与基于 PRISMA 框架的系统文献综述(SLR)相结合。文献计量分析基于从 Scopus 检索到的 1,017 条记录,考察了出版…

阅读完整摘要 ↗
贫困仍然是一个由社会不平等、基本服务获取受限以及环境风险驱动的持续性全球挑战。尽管在减少极端贫困方面取得了进展,但实现包容性和可持续的减贫仍需有效的治理、基础设施建设和多维度的政策干预。本研究采用混合方法综述设计,将文献计量分析与基于 PRISMA 框架的系统文献综述(SLR)相结合。文献计量分析基于从 Scopus 检索到的 1,017 条记录,考察了出版趋势、地理分布、主要贡献者及主题演变,而系统文献综述则综合了 2015 年至 2024 年间发表的 51 篇符合条件的同行评审文章,深入探讨治理、基础设施、政策干预和多维贫困问题。研究结果显示,学术关注度持续上升,其中中国在实证研究方面处于领先地位,而西方国家则在概念和方法论创新方面走在前列。文献计量图谱识别出与大数据驱动分析、气候与环境风险、社会包容、性别及精准扶贫相关的新兴信号,而系统文献综述表明,性别相关研究在实质性层面仍代表性不足。本研究揭示了从农村发展向跨学科、基于证据且情境敏感的方法转变的趋势,为政策制定者和研究人员在推进与可持续发展目标 1(无贫穷)相一致的策略方面提供了见解。
查看原文摘要
Poverty remains a persistent global challenge driven by social inequality, limited access to essential services, and environmental risks. Despite progress in reducing extreme poverty, inclusive and sustainable alleviation requires effective governance, infrastructure development, and multidimensional policy interventions. This study employs a mixed-methods review design that combines bibliometric analysis with a systematic literature review (SLR) using the PRISMA framework. The bibliometric analysis was conducted on 1,017 records retrieved from Scopus to examine publication trends, geographical patterns, key contributors, and thematic evolution, while the SLR synthesized 51 eligible peer-reviewed articles published between 2015 and 2024 for in-depth examination of governance, infrastructure, policy interventions, and multidimensional poverty. Findings reveal growing scholarly attention, with China leading empirical research and Western countries advancing conceptual and methodological innovations. Bibliometric mapping identifies emerging signals related to big data-driven analysis, climate and environmental risks, social inclusion, gender, and targeted poverty alleviation, and the SLR indicates that gender-related research remains substantively underrepresented. The study highlights a shift from rural development toward interdisciplinary, evidence-based, and context-sensitive approaches, offering insights for policymakers and researchers in advancing strategies aligned with Sustainable Development Goal 1 (No Poverty).

小城市中的信息自由公开:来自意大利的证据

Lorenzo Cicatiello, Giuseppe Lucio Gaeta, Sabrina Ruberto, Fabrizio Di Mascio

英文原题

FOI Publicity in Small Municipalities: Evidence From Italy

本实证研究探讨了小型市政当局中信息自由(FOI)公开的实施模式。这些市政当局因财政和人力资源有限,在执行国家政策时可能面临重大挑战。我们的分析利用了从特定意大利市政当局样本官方网站审查中收集的数据。通过采用层次聚类和回归分析技术,我们的研究结果强调了小型市政当局在 FOI 公开实施中所面临的关键挑战。

阅读完整摘要 ↗
本实证研究探讨了小型市政当局中信息自由(FOI)公开的实施模式。这些市政当局因财政和人力资源有限,在执行国家政策时可能面临重大挑战。我们的分析利用了从特定意大利市政当局样本官方网站审查中收集的数据。通过采用层次聚类和回归分析技术,我们的研究结果强调了小型市政当局在 FOI 公开实施中所面临的关键挑战。
查看原文摘要
This empirical study investigates the implementation patterns of freedom of information (FOI) publicity within small municipalities. These municipalities, characterized by limited financial and human resources, are likely to face substantial challenges in executing national policies. Our analysis leverages data collected from an examination of the official websites of a specific sample of Italian municipalities. Utilizing hierarchical cluster and regression analysis techniques, our findings underscore the critical challenges in the FOI publicity implementation among small municipalities
正在读取当前内容...
研读新知 · 栏目
我的阅读


摘要 · ABSTRACT